ABUSE
"To have a prison that's chaotic, poorly run,
dangerous, didn't provide services, highly sexualized and highly violent
really limits the ability of the state to turn those folks around, and
to ensure public safety upon their release from prison."
Jonathan Smith, chief of special litigation in the civil rights section
at the Justice Department, about GEO's Walnut Grove Detention Center.
NPR, April 24, 2012
"The sum of these actions and inactions ... paints a
picture of such horror as should be unrealized anywhere in the civilized
world."
U.S. District Judge Carlton
Reeves in his settlement order against the State of Mississippi for its
role at GEO's Walnut Grove Correctional Facility. Sun Herald,
March 29, 2012
"These shadowy private companies who profit from children being
locked up have disguised their methods of painful holds on children for
years. It is time we revealed what is really happening."
Frances Crook, director of the Howard League (UK), on the use of illegal
restraints on youth in private prisons.
The Independent, April 25, 2011
"This isn't even what we know of as a
prison - this is a gulag."
Steven Pevar, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union, said
in 34 years of suing more than 100 prisons and jails, CCA's Idaho
Correctional Center is the most violent he has seen. AP, November
30, 2010
"You know cells are not nice places, let's be very clear about that."
Australian Corrections Minister Bob Cameron when asked if it was
appropriate for people to be denied access to fresh air and daylight for
days at GEO's Melbourne Detention Centre. AAP, February 25, 2010
"These are children we are talking about. It is unacceptable that
they are detained at all."
Donna Covey, chief executive of the Refugee Council (UK) about a report
on the treatment of children at Serco's Yarl's Wood prison. InTheNews,
February 17, 2010
“Poor medical care was the most problematic issue facing the
facility."
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) investigators 2008 report on
MTC's Willacy County Federal Detention Facility. Texas Tribune,
November 17, 2009
"Although the government contends that any weight loss experienced by
inmates is 'healthy' weight loss, the court is not persuaded that a
mandatory weight reduction plan for overweight inmates is a legitimate
penological objective of the jail."
U.S. District Court Judge Todd Campbell ordered a Robertson County Jail
inmate moved to another detention facility after the man and other
inmates complained about inadequate food at the jail. WSMV,
October 27, 2009
"Is there a problem at Otter Creek right now? Definitely so.”
Kentucky State Police spokesman Mike Goble on a series of allegations of
rape at CCA's Otter Creek Correctional Center. Courier-Journal,
August 2, 2009
“Clearly, Mr. Rivera-Barnes’ conduct was deplorable. His conduct is
not becoming of the type of employee that we want at Wyatt.”
Wyatt Detention Center (RI) Bill Fischer, the jail’s spokesman, on former
Cornell employee sexually assaulting detainees. Providence Journal,
July 30, 2009
“We strongly believe there is no such thing as consensual sex
(between guards and inmates).”
Kentucky DOC spokeswoman Lisa Lamb on a the state's law making sexual
contact with inmates a misdemeanor. A number of allegations of sexual
abuse at CCA's Otter Creek prison led to exposing this injustice.
Courier-Journal,
July 26, 2009
"We continue to have concerns about the facility to maintain health
and safety for the kids."
Pennsylvania welfare department spokeswoman Stacey L. Witalec on the
state's suspending sending kids to Cornell's troubles New Morgan
Academy. Reading Eagle, July 14, 2009
"If these issues are being repeated
that's a matter of great concern, because this is not rocket science."
Former head of Queensland's corrective services, Keith Hamburger, on the
death of a tribal elder in a prisoner transport van years after a
scathing report on Global Solutions (now Group 4) management. Four
Corners, June 15, 2009
"My concern relates to inmate safety
at ICC resulting from the increased violence in recent months."
Former Virtual Prison Program Warden Randy Blades (ID) about concerns
over CCA not fully investigating cases of inmate-on-inmate violence and
weren't reporting major inmate crimes to the Ada County Sheriff's office
for investigation and prosecution. The Olympian, April 4, 2009
“It’s ironic that these undocumented immigrants are barred from
working legally in the community, but while behind bars, they are not
only allowed but encouraged to work for a dollar a day."
Rutgers University criminal justice professor Michael Welch on ICE's
program to work illegal immigrants while in detention prisons.
Houston Chronicle, March 26, 2009
"If it is true that staff employed to work with asylum-seekers and
immigrants are members of the BNP then it is yet another sign that the
Home Office are allowing for the mistreatment of immigrants in this
country."
Labour MP and anti-racist campaigner Diane Abbott on revelations that
two private prison guards were members of an ultra-right wing political
group. Politics.Co.UK January 14, 2009
"This prosecution affirms our strong commitment to protecting the
constitutional rights of individuals not to be subjected to unjustified
and excessive force by officers whose duty it is to uphold the law."
U.S. Attorney Benton Campbell about four GEO guards who dragged,
stripped and then hit a detainee in the neck repeatedly as his head
slammed against the wall. NBC New York, November 20, 2008
"They would go to Frank's door,
look in on Frank, [ask] 'Frank, you all right?' As long as he was living
and breathing in that cell, they kept moving."
Patrick Perry, former CCA Captain on why inmate Frank Horton was left in
solitary confinement for over nine months because prison officials
refused to forcibly remove him. Perry claimed it was because they feared
too many incidents involving force could jeopardize staff's yearly
bonuses.
NewsChannel 5,
October 30, 2008
"Obviously, whether he was enticed or lured or not, we've got a major
breakdown in training with the staff at Otter Creek, and a problem with
accountability up there of guards if a person can go in there and commit
this type of act against one of our inmates."
Hawai'i State Sen. Will Espero, chairman of the Senate Public Safety
Committee, on the rape of an Hawai'i inmate at CCA's Otter Creek (KY)
Prison. Honolulu Advertiser, October 2, 2008
“There are things that occur in jails. It's a different society all
in its own. Through surveillance, through patrols, through techniques
utilized in the corrections facility, we try to minimize that."
Torrance County (NM) Sheriff Clarence Gibson trying to explain away
his CCA's jail highest level of rape then any jail in the US. KOAT,
October 1, 2008
“It was going on a lot. It was going on almost all the time, the
sexual abuse.”
Former GEO Group detainee about sex between guards and inmates at the
South Texas Detention Complex. WOAI,
May 16, 2008
"It's ridiculous to have anybody live like that. To me, that's not even
human."
Mary Braswell, Frank Horton's grandmother about how her mentally
ill grandson went 9 months without a shower at CCA's Metro-Davidson
Detention Center in Nashville, Tennessee. Tennessean, March 24,
2008
“It might be more realistic to empty the centre briefly, so that it
can be relaunched with a properly trained and reinvigorated staff,
focused on plenty of good-quality, purposeful activity, dynamic
security, and an emphasis on appropriate behaviour within clear
boundaries.”
Anne Owers, UK Chief Inspector of Prisons, suggestion to close the jail
after finding a lack of control and order at
Group 4's Oakhill Secure Training Unit. The Times, March 17, 2008
"Sometimes you need to restrain a child to protect them from themselves,
but there is a difference between restraining a child and beating a
child."
Carol Pounder, mother of Adam Rickwood who killed himself after a being
hit by a guard at Serco run Hassockfield Secure Training Centre in the
UK. The Northern Echo, March 8, 2008
"It angers me that it took these people dying and full embarrassment in
the press for this to happen."
Penny Ryder, of the American Friends Service Committee on the release of
a scathing report on the health care provided by Correctional Medical
Services in Michigan Prisons. Grand Rapid Press, February 6, 2008
"It's humiliating."
Lead class-action plaintiff Stephen D. Bussy on being strip-searched
at GEO's George W. Hill Correctional Facility in Pennsylvania on a
misdemeanor charges. AP, January 31, 2008
"He just came in and started choking me, and getting on top of me, and
grabbing my hands and pulling them behind my back and stuff like that,
and grabbing me in private areas."
Former GEO juvenile detention inmate Deon Olthoff, 18, on being abused
by a registered sex offender that GEO hired as a guard at the Coke
County Juvenile Justice Center. Dallas Morning News, December 6,
2007
"It pains me to think of all the people who have been mistreated there in
the years since we first raised the issue. If the authorities had
listened to us, then all that suffering could have been avoided."
Former Melbourne Custody Center employee Ros
Atkinson on how her information on abuse was ignored by GEO Group and
others. The Herald Sun, November 24, 2007
"I have received complaints from prisoners about their treatment by
custodial staff, particularly allegations of assault."
Victorian Ombudsman George Brouwer
on a beating of a detainee at GEO's Melbourne Custody Center. The Age,
November 22, 2007
"It was not an assault. It was something that was consensual."
Evelyn Hernandez of the CCA's T. Don Hutto Detention Center about
the rape of a detainee there. KXAN,
October 31, 2007
"It seemed there was no end to the degradation he and other prisoners
were to endure with substandard facilities."
Shirley Noble, who told a Texas Legislative Committee how her son,
43-year-old Idaho inmate Scot Noble Payne, endured months of horrific
conditions then slit his own throat at a private Texas prison run by GEO
Group. KRIS TV, October 12, 2007
"The unsafe conditions I witnessed at Coke County this weekend are
unacceptable. We have zero tolerance for any form of abuse within the
system, and those responsible parties will be held accountable."
Texas Youth Corrections Executive Director Dimitria Pope on announcing the
decision to cancel its contract with GEO Group at the Coke County
Juvenile Detention Center after a surprise visit uncovered some
continuing problems. Oops. Dallas Morning News, October 2, 2007
"While there were issues with the standards in terms of food service and
clothing and temperature and things like that, our reasons for taking
people out are really much more fundamental than that. We just have
serious doubts about Cornell at the facility."
Gary Mead, assistant director for
detention and removal operations for ICE, on why ICE removed their
detainees from Cornell's Regional Correctional Center in Albuquerque,
New Mexico. Albuquerque Tribune, September 13, 2007
"They know that the child got injured somehow. They just don't know how."
Rob Johnson, a spokesman for regulators in Tennessee on the lack of
oversight at the Chad Youth Enhancement Center. Philadelphia Inquirer,
August 5, 2007
"If a jail treats its employees that way, how is it going to treat
inmates?"
GEO guard's Attorney Mark Anthony Sanchez on GEO's Val Verde Prison upon
learning Idaho was shipping inmates to the troubled facility. His client
won a verdict against GEO for racial discrimination. The Olympian,
July 10, 2007
"Is there any warrant for shackling the feet
and binding the chest of an innocent detainee?"
Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Senior Judge John Noonan on CCA's
handling of an immigration detainee. Metropolitan News-Enterprise,
December 7, 2004
"We're very concerned, We're very concerned."
CCA spokeswoman Cathie Sullivan on how male guard was allowed to get
access to a 17-year-old female inmate he allegedly raped. Hernando Today,
December 1, 2004
"We have yet to find one of these organizations or individuals who
can substantiate any of these claims, except maybe for an isolated incident that
may have occurred years ago. I would challenge them to prove any of these
allegations."
Steve Owen, CCA spokesman on allegations that CCA cuts corners, has little
oversight and is one of the worst prison management systems nationwide. ZWire,
May 23, 2004
ACCREDITATION
ACA accreditation does not determine constitutionality.
See Bell v. Wolfish, 441 U.S. at 543 n. 27; Rufo v. Inmates of Suffolk County
Jail, 502 U.S. 367, 391 n. 13 (1992). "It is absurd to suggest that the federal
courts should subvert their judgment as to alleged Eighth Amendment violations
to the ACA whenever it has relevant standards." Gates v. Cook, 376 F.3d 323, 337
(5th Cir. 2004). Although ACA standards "may be a relevant consideration,"
compliance with them "is not per se evidence of constitutionality." Id. "[A]ccreditation,
in itself, is not a clear indication that [defendant] is properly following its
policies and procedures." Ruiz v. Johnson, 37 F.Supp.2d 855, 924 (D. Tex. 1999)
rev'd and remanded on other grounds by Ruiz v. U.S., 243 F.3d 941 (5th Cir.
2001).
"Are we concerned
when an incident happens at an accredited facility? The answer is yes."
ACA Executive Director James Gondles after a series of riots at GEO
Groups' ACA accredited Reeves County Detention Center. KRISTV,
February 6, 2009
"You
can have a good jail and still not be accredited."
Leflore County, Mississippi Sheriff Ricky Banks on cutting ACA accreditation
contract requirement for CCA's Delta Correctional Facility. Greenwood
Commonwealth, September 7, 2005
BENEFITS
"Currently, Cornell offers a health insurance package, but the
employees have to pay 100 percent of the premium."
Valencia County Administrator Michael Oliver on Cornell. Albuquerque
Journal, December 29, 2004
"We'll be making our current wages, (but) we'll be losing out on
several things. If you don't have a county job, you don't have the retirement.
What we've put (into our retirement), we'll get, but it won't continue."
Coshocton County Justice Center cook Janet Swaney on Aramark's take over of
the jail food contract. Coshocton Tribune, July 23, 2004
BONDING
“A failed auction would maintain financial pressure on the
city, forcing it to continue with the current practice of cobbling together
debt-service payment amounts from various sources.”
Fitch analyst Steve Murray on up coming auction of former GEO managed Bill
Clayton Detention Center. Bondbuyer, July 19, 2011
"It was built to bring economic development to the city of Littlefield."
Danny Davis, Littlefield, Texas city manager, on the Bill Clayton Detention
Center (formerly run by GEO) not having a single inmate in the last two years.
KCBD, February 3, 2011
“If we do not do it, we lose the jail, we lose the property, and our bond
rating goes down so bad that we won’t be able to get any loans anymore.”
McLennan County (TX) Commissioner Joe Mashek on CEC's possible default on bonds
for their Jack Harwell Detention Center. Waco Tribune-Herald, May 6, 2010
"We have enough to make at least the next three payments."
Danny Davis, Littlefield (TX) city manager on the possible default on $10
million in bonds owed after GEO pulled out of local jail contract. Lubbock
On-line, December 13, 2008
"Its scary territory."
Montana Department of Corrections Kerry Pribnow, a bid evaluation panel member
's concerns about CEC's proposal for the use of their Two Rivers Jail after
defaulting on the bonds. Billings Gazette, September 26, 2008
"I feel bad for the people of Hardin and understand that they want jobs.
But I don't feel that this was handled appropriately, nor do I think we should
base economic development on prison beds."
Montana State Senator Steve Gallus on a failed CiviGenics plan to hold inmates
at a county jail in Hardin. Billings Gazette, January 7, 2008
"It's a small ripple, but it is fair to say that people in Montana who
have their savings invested in tax-exempt mutual funds stand a chance to lose
part of their asset value."
Michael Harling, executive vice president of Municipal Capital Markets on
the possible default of bonds floated to build a CiviGenics jail. The Gazette,
January 23, 2008
"Deprived of its essential function by state action, the detention center
will face potentially catastrophic loss, including possible default on financing
commitments."
Suit filed against the Montana's Attorney General 's opinion that
Hardin County had no authority to import inmates from out of state into a CiviGenics jail. Billings Gazette,
December 12, 2007
"The problem is, once that reserve fund is tapped, it becomes an event of
default. (A default) casts a sort of pallor over it in the financial world. That
isn't great, and we don't want that."
Michael Harling, executive vice president of Municipal Capital Markets on
the Montana's Attorney General 's opinion that Hardin County had no authority to
import inmates from out of state into a CiviGenics jail. Billings Gazette,
December 4, 2007
"They issue the bonds, take on the debt and the promise is always if
something goes wrong, there's no risk because the county didn't issue the bonds,
the PFC (Public Facility Corporation) issued the bonds. But rating agencies
don't differentiate between a PFC and the county. If the PFC goes default, its
the same as if the county did."
Dr. Sean Chadwell, former Encinal, Texas city councilman on private bonding
of prisons.
“They said they were worried about losing our bond
rating, and that’s why we should continue to operate the facility. We lost it
(bond rating) anyway."
Hood County, Texas Judge Andy Rash about MTC pulling out of a COP issue.
Hood County News, February 1, 2006
"If somebody has the ability to pass a tax issue or a bond, I think
they'd be foolish not to. That's still the cheapest and the best way to
go."
Municipal Capital Markets VP Michael Harling on the use of Certificates of Participation
vs. bonding for building prisons. For-profits use the COPs to get around voters
on bond issues. Correctional News, July 23, 2004
CHERRY-PICKING
“It’s cherry-picking. They leave the most expensive prisoners with
taxpayers and take the easy prisoners.”
Arizona State Representative Chad Campbell
on research, by the Arizona Department of Corrections, that reveals a murky
aspect of private prisons that helps them appear less expensive: They often
house only relatively healthy inmates. New York Times, May 18, 2011
"If
you're cherry-picking the very best prisoners, like private schools do with
students, the state ends up with the worst ones, thereby driving up our costs."
Minnesota state Rep. Debra Hilstrom on sending inmates to CCA's Prairie
Correctional Facility. Pioneer Press,
March 13, 2005
COST
“Now, this riot will create substantial costs to us.”
Beckham County (OK) District Attorney Dennis Smith on the effect a riot at CCA's
North Fork CF will have on his budget and that of the local community. NPR,
July 26, 2012
"We have saved a tremendous amount of money with the sheriff
coming in and running the jail. The cost is substantially lower than with CCA."
Hernando County (FL) Commissioner John Druzbick on the Sheriff's job taking over
the county jail from CCA. Hernando Today, January 8, 2012
"They said they couldn't make it on that."
Mississippi Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps on CCA's decision to pull out of
its contract with the state at the Delta Correctional Facility after they
determined they could not meet the cost savings requirement. AP,
November 10, 2011
"We would certainly like to talk with the state of Mississippi
about them employing a full-time investigator that would investigate the major
crimes, your felony crimes that occur on that facility. And free up my
investigators to work for the citizens of Lauderdale County."
Lauderdale County (MS) Sheriff Billy Sollie on having to investigate incidents
at GEO's East Mississippi Correctional Facility. WTOK, October 31, 2011
"It's a disgrace for the private prisons to be getting the per diem they're
getting."
Henderson County (KY) Jailer Ron Herrington on the state paying more to
CCA than to counties for housing inmates. Evansville Courier & Press,
October 18, 2011
“You might save a little bit. But then you have to pay for the
outsourcing, which is more than you are going to save. No one has poked holes in
our numbers yet. No one has said to me, ‘Commissioner, your numbers are out of
whack.’”
New Hampshire Corrections Commissioner Bill Wrenn told the Senate Finance
Committee the move to privatize would actually cost the state. NHPR, May
13, 2011
"There's a pattern of non-compliance that's raised some questions of
whether or not taxpayers are getting their money's worth."
Kentucky State Auditor Crit Luallen on her report on Aramark's contract with the
Department of Corrections. Lexington Herald-Leader, October 8, 2010
"I think we need to see the magnitude of the payments that haven’t been
made. If we are talking about millions of dollars, then absolutely I am
concerned about it fiscally and policy-wise. I can assure you that the private
operators wouldn’t stand idly by if the state wasn’t meeting its contractual
obligations.”
NM Sen. Peter Wirth on DOC Secretary Williams not enforcing liquidated damages
for guard vacancies against Williams' former employer Wackenhut (GEO Group) and
CCA. New Mexico Independent, September 2, 2010
"There shouldn't be any surprise when something like this happens. Their
product is the incarceration of criminals and it's a for-profit business."
Justin Jones, Oklahoma
Corrections Department director on the announcement by CCA that state inmates
were not as profitable as federal inmates so the state might have to move its
inmates out of CCA prisons to make room for larger profits. The Oklahoman,
August 22, 2010
"Cost savings like that don't come without consequences. And that can
present a security risk that's elevated."
Travis Pratt, a professor of criminology and criminal justice at Arizona State
University, on purported cost savings by the for-profits. Arizona Republic,
August 22, 2010
"It's part of our effort to reduce our financial burden."
Lisa Lamb, a spokeswoman for the Kentucky Department of Corrections on removing
its inmates from CCA's Lee Adjustment Center. AP, June 22, 2010
"We're a partner in this, not a for-profit company running it to milk
it."
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on taking over the County Jail from
CCA. St Petersburg Times,
May 25, 2010
"In 2009, the sheriff's budget, entire budget, with insurance, building
payments, power, everything, was $1.3 million cheaper than it was in 2008 under
CCA's operation."
Bay County (FL) commissioner Mike Thomas on CCA's claims that it would have
saved money if it had continued to run the Bay County Jail. WJHG, March
11, 2010
"That's absolutely laughable. If that were the case, they'd be out of
here.''
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on CCA's claim they were loosing
money at the County Jail.
St Petersburg Times, March 4, 2010
"We're not getting back what we're owed."
Miami-Dade County Commissioner Joe Martinez, who voted against a settlement with
Wackenhut over ghost employees, etc. A county audit found up to $5.8
million in payments for work not performed but the county settled for $3 million
from Wackenhut. Miami-Herald, February 19, 2010
“And PHS would say, ‘It’s too expensive, or not on our formulary.’ It was
hard to see something so simple to do for someone and not be able to get it
done. There was so much pressure not to prescribe.”
Lorene Gendron, who worked for PHS (in VT) for two years as an inmate
advocate, says that poor support, salaries and working conditions mean high
turnover. Ashley Ellis died less than two days after entering a Vermont prison
from the careless and negligent operation of a privatized for-profit (PHS)
prison healthcare system. In These Times,
December 8, 2009
"The county regrets that in order to protect its interest, the
extraordinary approach of withholding the funds was necessary,'' Gantt wrote.
"However, the amendment (related to the new beds) noted had been in place for 20
months, and the revenue share due the county had not been paid as stipulated in
any semblance."
Hernando County (FL) Purchasing Director James Gantt on CCA's reneging on a
shared revenue plan. St Petersburg Times, July 28, 2009
"We have been in discussion with them since that was implemented on how
that will be done but haven't received the revenue that we anticipated."
Hernando County (FL) Purchasing Director James Gantt on CCA's reneging on a
shared revenue plan.
Hernando Today, July 3, 2009
"It seemed pretty apparent they were cutting -- they were trying to be
ultra-efficient, cutting back as much as they could. If things would break down,
they'd stay broken down for a long time -- exercise equipment, telephones."
Convicted former Rep. Vic Kohring (AK) on his stay at the Taft Correctional
Institution (CA) run by MTC.
Anchorage Daily-News, June 13, 2009
"(LCS) came in with a low, low price to take these Vermont inmates which
is very attractive to state governments in these tough economic times.”
Vermont prisoner rights group Managing Attorney Seth Lipschutz on LCS
low-balling costs for Vermont inmates at LCS' Perry County (AL) Detention Center
after Vermont pulled its inmates after a number of assaults. Seven Days,
May 27, 2009
"They said we won't know until all the bids come in."
Reeves County (TX) Judge Sam Contreras on the estimated $1.1 million in repairs
the county will make because of two riots at their GEO run prison. KRIS TV,
February 25, 2009
“The company that ran the jail until 2006 hadn’t made some repairs so we
held onto the payment in exchange for the repairs.”
Liberty County (TX) Judge Phil Fitzgerald on why the county was releasing
funds to Community Education Centers, the company that used to run the jail,
because they paid Civigenics, the company that now runs the jail, to make the
repairs. Cleveland Advocate, January 14, 2009
"One of our intentions is to have them explain, in writing, how they were
not able to fulfill their obligations."
Bay County (FL) Attorney Terrell Arline on CCA pulling out of the Bay
County Jail due to lowballing costs.
News-Herald, June 17, 2008
"Our experience with this project has taught us some important lessons,
and this, along with the other improvements put in place, has led to an overall
positive impact for the public."
A UK Home Office spokesperson on a report showing the Home Office squandered
£29million of taxpayers' money on a flagship giant asylum centre which was never
built - including hiring in a 'financial advisor' who charged almost £16,000 a
month. Mail on Sunday, June 11, 2008
"My problem is they're not sticking around long enough for Bay County to
realize if the design is one that is going to save us money. If it's what we
paid for."
Bay County Florida Commissioner George Gainer on CCA's decision to drop its
contract with the County right after winning the contract to build a new jail.
News-Herald, May 14, 2008
"I think you saw us [in] April at our worst."
Ernie Dixon, director of operations for The GEO Group, about the costs
a riot in 2007 at GEO's New Castle Correctional Facility is causing. The Star
Press, April 24, 2008
“It’s a slippery slope when every provider gets a different rate."
Patrick Brodhead, an analyst for the Colorado Joint Budget Committee on CCA
getting a three percent increase out of the state after threatening to remove CO
inmates if the state didn't pay. The Daily Sentinel, March 11, 2008
"We've got a negotiating disadvantage. The choice we've got to make is to
give them a provider rate increase that is three times what we're giving to all
other providers, or to build hundreds of millions of dollars in additional
prisons. We don't have that hundreds of millions of dollars, and they know it.
The decisions that have been made over the last 12 years (in using private
prisons) have put us in a very difficult negotiating position."
Colorado Representative and Joint Budget Commitee Chairman Bernie Buescher on
CCA's demands for a 5 percent increase in payments from the state.
Pueblo Chieftain, February 6, 2008
"This bartering has gone on for better than a year now and I believe it's
publicly embarrassing for both entities. For us to threaten lawsuit to go after
monies that's rightfully ours is absurd. But to have mediated for anything less
would have done a disservice to the public taxpayers who depend on those
allocated revenues for infrastructure improvements."
Eloy, Arizona Mayor Byron Jackson about ongoing debate with CCA over the
payment of construction taxes.
Casa Grande Valley News, December 27, 2007
"I believe and this government believes, that our people have frankly
received poor value, if not been ripped off, in many instances, by many flagship
projects."
Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill on Sodexho's Addiewell Prison.
Press Association, December 4, 2007
"They have a blanket policy to keep their fingers crossed and hope these
people are no longer their problem."
Greg Lauer, a Fort Lauderdale lawyer, on Armor's attempts at cost cutting at
the expense of inmates at the Broward County Detention Center. South Florida
Sun-Sentinel, November 27, 2007
"It tells me I shouldn't be running to privatization."
Utah Department of Corrections Director Tom Patterson on a study
showing no reason for the state to privatize. Salt Lake City Tribune,
September 20, 2007
"The cost to make those repairs would actually be double that, because
we'd have to finance them, and we still wouldn't own the building."
Mike Sieving, Hamilton County, Ohio construction project executive, on the
$44 million in repairs required at the CCA prison the county rents. City Beat,
September 12, 2007
“We think we can save between 10 and 15 percent which is critical to us
right now.”
Anthony Ventetuolo Jr., president of Avcorr Consulting on local detention
facility corporation taking control of management from Cornell at the Wyatt
Detention Facility, Rhode Island. Providence Journal-Bulletin, June 22,
2007
“It’s been a nightmare. I’m not voting for spending one more thin dime
until we get our grant.”
Moore Haven, Florida Councilman John Ahern on hearing the $9 million
engineering bill for water extension to GEO's prison. Glades County Democrat,
June 13, 2007
"Business decisions across two administrations may result in New Mexico
paying an estimated $34 million more than it should pay for private prison
construction costs."
From audit by a New Mexico Legislative Finance Committee review team. New
Mexico's private-prison spending rose 57 percent in the past six years. New
Mexican, May 24, 2007
“It was the first time I’d heard we were actually going to have to put up
money”
Adams County, MS Supervisor Henry Watts on CCA's not being upfront with all
the costs for their prison proposal. Natchez Democrat, May 3, 2007
''I'm surprised because
of the way the last contract was handled and terminated and because they were
not the lowest bidder. My concern has always been making sure that the state
fulfilled its end of the contract by imposing the fines"
Florida Senator Dave Aronberg upon learning that the DOC had given a
contract back to Prison Health Services including an extra $250 million after
they pulled out because they weren't making enough money on the first contract.
Tallahassee Democrat, October 24, 2006
"You're dealing with a private
business here, and they are in it to make money and answer to shareholders. Our
mission is public safety, and the ideologies don't always line up"
Oklahoma Corrections Director Justin Jones on Cornell's plan to evict state
inmates for higher paying federal inmates. The Oklahoman, October 12,
2006
"It's the nature of the beast.
That's why these people get contracts, and not just with us. They get contracts
across the country because government is looking for ways to save taxpayer
money, and that's exactly what we're doing."
Hernando County, Florida Purchasing Director Jim Gantt on why their CCA
jail has high guard turnover. St. Petersburg Times, February 5, 2006
"We've tried it and it did not
work. In my opinion, they can't do it better for less."
Arkansas Prison Director Larry Norris on privatization cost savings.
Arkansas News, January 13, 2006
“A Fortune 500 company like Corrections Corporation of America can’t fix
a toilet?”
Bay County, Florida Public Defender Walter Smith on CCA's inability to fix a
toilet for over three months at their Bay County Jail. News Herald,
January 11, 2006
"We were really surprised
they not only bid on the Florida business but bid as low as they did. This is
truly one of the most risky contracts that any prison health company could enter
into."
Mark Hale, executive vice president and chief operating officer of Wexford, on
Prison Health Services award of a Florida Department of Corrections contract.
Ft Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel, January 9, 2006
"That's a costly remedy
for the situation."
Idaho Gov. Kenpthorne spokesman Mike Journee on the cost of shipping inmates
out-of-state to CCA's prison in Minnesota. Casper Star Tribune, November
15, 2005.
"It was too expensive to treat
both."
Former First Correctional Medical employee, Dr. Ramesh Vemulapalli, on being
told to treat inmate AIDS or hepatitus C -- but not both in Delaware. Wilmington
News Journal, September 26, 2005
"It's going to cost the state a lot of money in the long run."
Dr. Robert Cohen on state a federal lawsuits Delaware faces regardless of
Correctional Medical Services indemnification. Wilmington News Journal,
September 25, 2005.
"CCA
is adequate, but the fact is that costs are outpacing revenues and have brought
us to this point. We'd like to see the jail operate within the existing revenues
and not be an additional burden to the tax payers."
Tulsa
County Undersheriff Brian Edwards on rising jail costs at CCA's David L. Moss
Jail in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Tulsa World, January 26, 2005
"We want to be paid as much as the private
jails."
Kenton County jailer Terry Carl on Kentucky paying for-profits $30.49 to $44.19
per day vs. $26.51 to county jails. News Enquirer, January 2, 2005
"I'm
not, obviously, going to say we've wasted money."
Florida Juvenile Justice Association lobbyist Mark Fontaine on
juvenile transfers increasing cost to the taxpayer. Orlando Sentinel, December
19, 2004
"One of my concerns is the county's broke, I cut my budget 20
percent from what I requested. The county does not have the money to pick up
funding of the jail."
Tulsa County Oklahoma Sheriff
Stanley Glanz on CCA's five-year 32% per diem increase at the David L. Moss
Criminal Justice Center. Tulsa World, October 28, 2004
"Trying to save money by cutting corrections
is scary for the public's safety"
Joe Lang, attorney for Cornell, told Valencia County,
NM commissioners when the county took back control of their jail. Albuquerque
Journal, September 22, 2004
''Without
those capital improvements to the building, CCA's liability was too great to
continue the contract.''
CCA spokeswoman Louise Chickering on why CCA won't spend $2.5 million on
sprinklers for its Tall Trees buildings and therefore cancelled its contract. Tennessean,
August 17, 2004
"The highest rate then for a residential treatment facility was
around $121 a day per child. No other facility in residential treatment in our
state was getting anything above that. And Cornell knew that."
South Dakota Child Protection Services administrator Virgena Wieseler on
Cornell's demand for $179 per child at its State Training School in Plankinton,
SD. Argus Leader, August 5, 2004
"Every contract is unique."
CCA spokeswoman on whether CCA was going to reimburse the government for
costs associated with a riot at their Crowley County CF in Colorado. Market
Watch, July 21, 2004
"That does change what is offered"
Debbie Albert of Aramark on why meal quality declined after a new contract
with New Mexico cut payments by about 20 cents per meal. The New Mexican,
July 9, 2004
"I don't know of any other budget in county government that's doubled in
five years."
Tulsa County Sheriff Stanley Glanz on CCA's increasing costs at the Tulsa
Jail. Daily Oklahoman, June 15, 2004
CORRUPTION
“The people who go back and forth come out really
well, but the taxpayers are the ones who aren’t well-served.”
New Mexico Sen. Cisco McSorley on former DOC Secretary Joe Williams
returning to GEO Group (formerly Wackenhut) where he worked before
becoming NM DOC Secretary. Williams refused to fine GEO and CCA for an
estimated $18 million. Albuquerque Journal, November 20, 2011
"This is all about the almighty dollars for the GEOs
of the world. It's all about political contributions that were made, and
the taxpayers are going to pay the consequences."
Florida Sen. Mike Fasano on learning that taxpayers will be on the hook
for a payout of up to $25 million to public correctional officers
loosing jobs because of prison privatization was hidden by legislative
leaders.
St Petersburg Times, August 17, 2011
"I've heard Gov. Christie say many times not to take a cup of
coffee from someone. With other social services programs being cut to
the bone, a program that could benefit a friend is increased. Why?"
Deborah Howlett, executive director of New Jersey Policy Perspective and
a former official in Gov. Jon S. Corzine's administration on the
revelation that a close friend, political contributor and adviser to
Gov. Chris Christie is a top-ranking employee of Community Education
Centers Inc., the largest company providing the state with treatment
centers for former inmates. The Daily Journal, June 21, 2010
"It's certainly no accident that this company made this
contribution and then got awarded the contract extension."
Bob Stern, president of the Center for Governmental Studies, after CCA
was awarded contract extensions by California without any re-bids and
CCA's hundred-thousands of dollars of contributions. Los Angeles
Daily Journal,
November 24, 2009
"It's the most serious judicial corruption scandal in our history
and the court took an extraordinary step in addressing it."
Marsha Levick, the Philadelphia-based Juvenile Law Center legal director
on the overturning by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court of thousands of
juvenile convictions due to two corrupt judges. AP, October 29,
2009
"This is corruption at the highest levels. This is not first time
this has happened and it comes despite Justice Minister Jack Straw
giving us an absolute assurance that it would not happen again."
Prison Officers Association (UK) general secretary Brian Caton on the
former prison governor Steve Hall, who had been appointed by the
National Offender Management Service (NOMS) to lead the privatization
bid, was revealed to have taken up a position with Serco. Morning
Star, September 4, 2009
"In this case, the fountain from which the public drinks is
confidence in the judicial system, a fountain which may be corrupted for
a time well after this case."
U.S. District Judge Edwin M. Kosik (PA) in rejecting a plea agreement
with two disgraced former Luzerne County Court judges accused of taking
kickbacks for sending juveniles to for-profit detention centers.
Philadelphia Inquirer, August 1, 2009
''I think it's time we asked and that they proffered. I think
it's a fair question and we'll be taking a look at it.''
Joe Rasco, director of the county (Miami-Dade) Office of
Intergovernmental Affairs when asked if it was a conflict of
interest for former-Congresswoman Carrie Meek to represent both the
County and Wackenhut while the County was overcharged by Wackenhut and
Wackenhut is suing the County. Miami-Herald, May 17, 2009
``We haven't been made whole. It would be irresponsible for us to
continue doing business with an entity that we believe has overbilled
us.''
Miami-Dade County (FL) spokeswoman Victoria Mallette on being sued by
Wackenhut (Group 4) after an audit and whistleblower suit uncovered
ghost employees. Miami Herald, April 30, 2009
"Not only did they delete the files, someone tried to cover their
tracks."
Prison Health Services attorney Tom Shults about Sarasota County (FL)
Sheriff Bill Blackwell deleting files on his computer related to his
relationship with Armor Correctional Health Services. Herald Tribune,
March 25, 2009
"I was the person who doctored the ACA accreditation reports for
this company."
Donna Como, former employee of CCA.
Pahrump Valley Times, December 19, 2008
“If you can’t live off the $87,585 that the taxpayers are giving
you, you need to get another job.”
McLennan County Sheriff candidate Charles Hutyra on the $12,000
"bonus" paid to the Sheriff from CEC. Tribune- Herald, October
20, 2008
"Had a great time! Give a call when you're ready to talk about
the contract and what you can do."
Sarasota County Sheriff Bill Balkwill in a letter to Armor Correctional
Health Services company executive Doyle Moore after a fishing trip the
Sheriff went on paid for by Armor. Herald-Tribune, May 13, 2008
"There is no disputing that [Miami-Dade Transit] was billed for
hours not worked by Wackenhut security officers, which is a very serious
offense.''
Miami-Dade County Manager George Burgess wrote in a memo to the Mayor
regarding an audit showing that Wackenhut overbilled the County
$6,000,000 for ghost employees. Miami-Herald, May 9, 2008
“It clarified the issue for me when I found out the sheriff is
getting $12,000 a year from the company leasing the jail. I’m not going
to accept funds from a private entity."
McLennan County Texas Sheriff candidate Randy Gates about the current
sheriff's receiving a $12,000 "stipend" from CiviGenics. Waco Tribune,
February 17, 2008
"I don't know what this money is for. I have some ethical
consideration regarding this money."
Webb County, Texas Commissioner Jerry Garza on GEO's offer of $250,000
to the Commission that no one knew what it was for. Laredo Morning
Times, November 14, 2007
"Just right now, I think it would be a bad idea to specifically
look for contributions from GEO."
Texas State Rep. Jerry Madden on his annual fundraiser partly
underwritten by GEO Group after one of its facilities was closed by the
Texas Youth Commission and GEO was under investigation by the
Legislature. Dallas Morning News, October 12, 2007
"Nobody in our department has worked for this company in the last
six or seven years. They've also worked for PHS. They've also worked for
about a dozen other companies. They go back and forth between the
companies and state service."
Alabama Department of Corrections Commissioner Richard Allen
defending his homeboys before legislative questioning about a CMS
contract award. I don't think realized what he said. Huntsville Times,
September 6, 2007
"The information that I got, from experts that reviewed the expenses,
says they could not justify the $50 million. They padded the construction costs
by an extra $20 to $15 million," Guerra said. "What is funny you get
commissioners that are indicted for taking $10,000. I am just wondering who are
the real crooks?" Willacy County, Texas District
Attorney Juan Guerra on how the county was sold private prisons. Killeen
Daily Herald, November 13, 2006
"I said at the time, in 2004, on the Whittier proposal, someone's going
to jail over this 'cause I could see how corrupt the process was." Alaska Representative Eric Croft on FBI investigation into corruption within
the legislature. Alaska Report,
September 1, 2006
"We’re not going to tolerate
companies coming in to take advantage of small counties and offering kickbacks
and going on like it’s business as usual. Whoever offers kickbacks is just as
guilty as those taking kickbacks." Texas District Attorney Juan Angel Guerra on alleged
bribes by Corplan and MTC. Valley Morning Star,
January 8, 2005
DRUGS
“A culture has arisen that drugs are more easily imported at evening and
weekend visits when, due to staffing levels, security is less."
Report of the the Independent Monitoring Board (UK) for the Kalyx (Sodexho)
Peterborough Prison.
Peterborough Today, August 21, 2010>
“The deterioration in safety and security arrangements, particularly the
significant increase in drug use and the weakness in staff supervision
of prisoners, are issues that can and must be addressed.”
Dame Anne Owers,
Chief Inspector of Prisons (UK) on a report that condemns Group 4's
Wolds Prison.
The Independent, July 6, 2010
"Making it appear the inmates are really in charge rather than the other
way around."
Florida DOC Inspector Carolyn Foster acknowledged to Circuit Judge Lucy
Chernow Brown that there is an ongoing problem with contraband at GEO's
South Bay prison. Palm Beach Post, January 5, 2010
"We received credible information alleging the SPOs (security police
officers) were involved in the activity and tested under our drug-free
workplace policy."
Courtney Henry of Wackenhut (Group 4) on firing some guards at the Oak
Ridge Nuclear plant for anabolic steroid use. Knoxville News Sentinel,
July 18, 2009
"It's appalling that a person paid to counsel inmates against drug abuse
is charged with trying to smuggle heroin and cocaine into the jail, the exact
opposite of what he was paid to do."
NY Department of Investigation Commissioner Rose Gill Hearn regarding the PHS
employee caught smuggling drugs into Rikers Island. New York Sun,
September 19, 2008
"They must be crazy. It's quite obvious when you walk in there and you
talk to people that they are on drugs. I don't know how you can pretend that
they aren't."
Response of former Global Solutions pastoral care worker and whistle-blower at
Villawood (Austrlaia), Pauline Lovitt, on immigration department not taking
serious her and other's claims about the facility. The Age, July 17, 2008
"Anyone, especially an employee, trying to deliver contraband into our
facility is taken very seriously."
Liberty County, Texas Sheriff Greg Arthur on two CiviGenics guards being charged
with drug smuggling.
Houston Chronicle, January 23, 2008
"The guards make $18,000 a year and the inmates are walking around with a
thousand dollars in cash on them"
Former GEO Group inmate David Eugene Davis about his experience at GEO's
Lawrenceville Correctional Facility in Virginia where over half the states
illegal drugs are found. Richmond Times-Dispatch, March 18, 2007
“It’s hard to comprehend that
someone would risk all that for $30.”
GEO Group's Val Verde County
Jail Warden John Campbell about guard being busted
for smuggling pot into the jail. Del Rio News-Herald, January 1, 2005
"This is not something we
anticipated with the jail."
Midland
(Canada) Police Chief Paul Hamel on the increase in crack-cocaine in the
community due to an MTC prison. The Mirror, September 29, 2004
EASE IN GETTING OUT OF CONTRACTS
"With the detention center, nothing has happened easy. It's been a
struggle for us all along, so, in some ways, we were not that surprised
that we've got a continued struggle."
Littlefield, TX, City Manager Danny Davis on news that the bid for his
empty prison formerly run by GEO fell through. KCBD, September
16, 2011
"We're not going to let the county be held hostage to CCA's tactics."
Hernando County
(FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on taking over the jail from CCA.
Hernando Today, August 27, 2010
"I cannot operate it without the proper equipment and I cannot operate it
without a sound structure."
Hernando County (FL) Jail's new administrator on the dispute and
on-going problems with taking over CCA's run jail. St Petersburg Times,
July 28, 2010
"We want to put these issues to bed."
Hernando County (FL) Administrator David Hamilton on the County's
dispute with CCA over who owns equipment at the jail. St Petersburg
Times, July 24, 2010
"Immediately exercise all appropriate legal measures to ensure that the
county-owned property remains in the jail."
Hernando County Sheriff Richard Nugent on CCA's actions to remove
equipment from the County Jail as the Sheriff plans on taking over from
CCA. St Petersburg Times, July 23, 2010
"I will not be threatened."
Hernando County (FL) Commissioner Jim Adkins on learning that CCA was
pulling out of its contract with the county saying the County made it
difficult for CCA to find inmates to make a profit for the company.
Hernando Today,
April 28, 2010
“When you use private prisons, you become hostage to their setting the
rate. And we always knew that this issue was out there.”
Colorado Representative Bernie Buescher on CCA's "extortion" of the state
use of CCA prison space. The Daily Sentinel, January 15, 2008
“They said that if we don’t essentially do a 5 percent increase over each
of the next five years, they will work at closing at least one of their prisons
to Colorado prisoners and start bringing in out-of- state prisoners.”
Colorado Representative Bernie Buescher on CCA's "extortion" of the state use of
CCA prison space. The Daily Sentinel, January 15, 2008
'I'm surprised because of the way
the last contract was handled and terminated and because they were not the
lowest bidder. My concern has always been making sure that the state fulfilled
its end of the contract by imposing the fines"
Florida Senator Dave Aronberg upon learning that the DOC had given a
contract back to Prison Health Services including an extra $250 million after
they pulled out because they weren't making enough money on the first contract.
Tallahassee Democrat, October 24, 2006
"You're dealing with a private business here, and they are in it to make
money and answer to shareholders. Our mission is public safety, and the
ideologies don't always line up"
Oklahoma Corrections Director Justin Jones on Cornell's plan to evict state
inmates for higher paying federal inmates. The Oklahoman, October 12,
2006
"Any plan to artificially reduce
the county jail population will invoke CiviGenics rights to exercise a 30-day
termination provision."
CiviGenics' Chief Operating Officer
Peter Argeropulos on forcing Columbiana County to keep the jail filled.
Salem News, August 12, 2006
“They (private-prison firms) kind of know they’ve got us over the barrel. “If
we don’t use them, we’ve got to ship people out of state. To a large extent, we
can’t dictate to them like we did in the ’90s. They would like to see us in
crisis when they open their doors.”
Dave Schouweiler, purchasing manager for the Colorado DOC on having to use
CCA and GEO. The Gazette,
July 31, 2006
"This state is stuck in a partnership with private corporations -- there
is no way that we can back out now."
Colorado DOC Executive Director Joe Ortiz on getting out of private prison
contracts. Pueblo Chieftain,
August 20, 2004
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
"Tasmanians were promised lots of jobs and that it would be of
real benefit to the Tasmanian community."
Tasmanian Liberal Senator Eric Abetz on Serco's decision to fire 36 guards and
replace them with cameras at their Pontville Detention Center. ABC News,
November 7, 2011
“It reminds me of that old country western song, she got the
gold mine and I got the shaft."
Broward County (FL) Property Appraiser Lori Parrish on CCA using a loophole to
avoid paying taxes on a piece of property CCA was going to develop. Local 10,
October 27, 2011
“This will put a tremendous strain on our police force. We’re going to need
as much help as we can get.”
Conneaut (OH) City Manager Timothy Eggleston about his town picking up the tab
for law enforcement at CCA's prison after it went from public to private. The
Star Beacon, October 11, 2011
"With the detention center, nothing has happened easy. It's been a struggle
for us all along, so, in some ways, we were not that surprised that we've got a
continued struggle."
Littlefield, TX, City Manager Danny Davis on news that the bid for his empty
prison formerly run by GEO fell through. KCBD, September 16, 2011
"They have to pay for it. And the people who's got it going are all up
and gone and they left us...Holdin' the bag!"
Tommy Kelton, a retiree, Littlefield, TX resident on getting stuck with the tab
for the empty GEO Bill Clayton Prison.
NPR, March
28, 2011
"They get the corporations formed, they get the bonds sold, they get the
facility built, their money is front-loaded, they take their money out. And then
there's no reason for them to support the success of the facility."
Former McLennan County Deputy Rick White about the empty CEC's McLennan County
Jail (TX) developers who put the deal together. NPR, March 28, 2011
"It was built
to bring economic development to the city of Littlefield."
Danny Davis, Littlefield, Texas city manager, on the Bill Clayton Detention
Center (formerly run by GEO) not having a single inmate in the last two years.
KCBD, February 3, 2011
“It’s just sad that the public has to pay for the legislature’s
irresponsibility."
Al Shopp with the Florida Police Benevolent Association on the cancellation of
prison work squads in order to fund an unneeded GEO prison. WCTV, August
10, 2010
"A lot of people felt like (CCA) let us down."
Jerry Clift, the former Trousdale County (TN) county executive on CCA stalling
to build a prison there because its sitting on over 12,000 empty beds else
where. Tennessean, August 9, 2010
“Who wants to lease a facility that you can’t flush the toilets?”
Two Rivers Authority’s (Hardin, MT) Jeff McDowell on picking up the cost to
replace burst pipes in their Corplan built empty prison. Billings Gazette,
June 23, 2010
“What we expected and what the studies had indicated have not
materialized at this point”
Peter Argeropulos, CEC senior vice president, on not being able to find inmates
for the Jack Harwell Detention Center. Waco Tribune-Herald, April 23,
2010
“Local taxpayers will pay more.”
Swift County (MN) Auditor Byron Giese about deal cut with CCA for their Prairie
Correctional Facility. The prison, which closed in February, had appealed its
$42.9 million valuation last fall, triggering a series of negotiation sessions.
West Central Tribune, March 17, 2010
“The fee serves no legitimate public purpose, and there is no rational
basis for the discrimination between CCA and any other entity housing prisoners
within the city.”
CCA lawsuit against Youngstown, Ohio on passing a $1 per-day per-prisoner tax on
them. The Vindicator,
January 26, 2010
"We knew Cornell was probably going to appeal. We certainly had no idea it
[the prison's value] would drop by $42 million."
Folkston City (GA) Manager Pender Lloyd said the Cornell appeal of the
D. Ray James Prison will cost his city at least $108,000 in anticipated tax
revenue - nearly a 5 percent cut to the city's $2.4 million budget.
Times-Union,
January 22, 2010
“We could also have the current jail filled with federal prisoners and that
could be something very profitable to the county.”
Webb County, TX Sheriff Martin Cuellar on losing $500,000 per year in
federal dollars to GEO Group. Texas Tribune, December 14, 2009
"It would bring jobs. Believe it or not, it would even bring hope and
opportunity."
Greg Smith, Hardin (MT) economic development director on trying to bring
terrorists from Gitmo to the $27 million empty prison sitting in his town.
CNN, May 26, 2009
“It’s been a challenge so far. I thought it would be easier.”
CCA's newly hired assistant warden Eric Staiger said of locating a
rental house for himself, his wife and their two kids in Natchez, MS. Natchez
Democrat, April 21, 2009
“The last thing we want in downtown for 20 years is a prison.”
Gainesville (GA) City Councilman Danny Dunagan on CCA's 20 year contract with
the County.
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, March 23, 2009
"They've got several million dollars already invested in it. I doubt
they're going to walk away from it."
Trousdale County (TN) chief development officer Tony Grande on news that
CCA was delaying the opening of its prison in his community due to financial
troubles. Tennessean, February 11, 2009
"Right now, we'd be contracting with a company in default."
Gary Willems, chief of Montana Corrections' Contracts and Facility
Management Bureau regarding the Civigenics Two Rivers jail built on spec and
sitting empty. The panel concluded that Two Rivers failed to show how it would
staff the jail with qualified workers, how it arrived at the per-day costs
previously quoted to the state and failed to show that the jail is financially
sound. The panel was particularly concerned that Two Rivers reported it would
still be in default, even if it won the contract.
Billings Gazette, November 11, 2008
"It doesn't look like the physical structure of the Hardin facility will
meet our needs."
Steve Lindly, deputy director of the Wyoming Department of Corrections, to
Peter Argeropulos, vice president of marketing for Community Education Centers,
on why Wyoming was not interested in using CEC's spec prison in Montana.
Casper Star-Journal, May 29, 2008
"I feel bad for the people of Hardin and understand that they want jobs.
But I don't feel that this was handled appropriately, nor do I think we should
base economic development on prison beds."
Montana State Senator Steve Gallus on a failed CiviGenics plan to hold inmates
at a county jail in Hardin. Billings Gazette, January 7, 2008
"There's a lack of work force up there. The population isn't there."
Montana state Sen. Trudi Schmidt on CCA's Crossroad's high turnover rate.
Great Falls Tribune, January 11, 2006
"Now,
they refuse to pay us ..."
Wheelwright, Kentucky Mayor David Sammons on CCA's refusal to pay a $10,000
per month payment to the town. AP, September 12, 2005
"They’re hitting us in the
pocketbook."
Willacy County, Texas Judge Simon
Salinas on the federal government not sending enough inmates into its MTC jail. Valley
Star, February 10, 2005
"(Companies and public agencies) site these
facilities where they'll find the least resistance and the cheapest land
costs."
Houston County Commissioner El Franco Lee on the Federal Bureau of Prisons not
taking public input on the siting of a private halfway house. Houston
Chronicle, November 22, 2004
“(Southern
Peaks) has already been a burden on law enforcement and a safety concern to the
community and it was not represented that way originally. It’s almost an
unfunded mandate when the court orders me to transport these kids.”
Fremont County, Colorado Sheriff
Jim Beicker on recent spate of escapes from Cornell's Southern Peaks Treatment
Facility. Canon Cafe, October 8, 2004
"Part of the workforce is going to have to move here."
Toole County (Montana) Commissioner Allan Underal acknowledging the
difficulty in finding qualified employees for CCA's planned prison expansion in
rural Montana. Great Falls Tribune, August 20, 2004
"We have heard so much about how it's going to bring business here.
Florence (AZ) has five prison, two of them private and that city has lost so
many people because of it. Florence doesn't even have a supermarket anymore.
What are we going to become."
Former Arizona corporation Commission attorney Patricia Cooper on MTC's
proposal for a 500-bed facility in Benson, AZ. Benson News, August 4,
2004
"We provide evidence that prison construction has actually impeded
economic growth in those rural communities that were already growing at a slower
pace. Among slow-growing counties, it appears that new prisons do more harm than
good."
Gregory Hooks, Chairman of the Department of Sociology at Washington State
University on a recent study on the economic impact of prisons on communities.
AScribe Newswire, July 19, 2004
"When this thing was built we had hoped there would be just more
than the jobs. At some point in time we'd hoped there would be some financial
benefit."
Pulaski County (IL) chairman Jerry Thurston on bringing GRW to run the
Tri-County jail. The Southern Illinoisan,
June 24, 2004
“They’re located in a for profit industrial park surrounded by
for-profit enterprises. They’ve got these bars on the windows. They’ve got
barbed wire on top of the fence, and they want to say they’re a residence? Give
me a break.”
Kansas State Rep. Candy Ruff, after CCA filed a property tax protest with
Leavenworth County, arguing that the prison should be classified as primarily
residential, rather than commercial, and thus qualify for a lower rate.
Kansas City Star, March 12, 1998
HIGH TURNOVER
"We have a lot of very young staff that have not integrated into very strong
security practices."
Odie Washington, a senior vice president at Management & Training Corp., acknowledged that the
Kingman prison (AZ) employed an inexperienced staff where three violent
prisoners escaped. Arizona Republic, August 22, 2010
"Unfortunately, private prisons are run to make a profit. Ultimately, the
company in charge of them has to deliver for their shareholders and so they have
to find ways to make money. The way to do this is by having fewer staff, paying
low wages, investing less money in training and pensions, and this impacts on
the running of the prison. For a prison to run properly, you need the guards and
the prisoners to understand each other and work with each other, and that
requires experienced guards. That takes an investment in training and keeping
staff, which can be at odds with the need to deliver a profit."
Former Chief Inspector of Prisons (Scotland) Sir Clive Fairweather on the cause
of a riot at the Kalyx (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. Edinburgh Evening News,
January 28, 2010
"Undoubtedly, a private company
would pay its employees significantly lower wages and provide them lesser
training to realize cost savings. This would lead to higher staff turnover, low
morale and place public safety at risk."
Arizona DOC Director Charles Ryan in a letter to Gov. Jan Brewer on a plan to
sell its public prisons to for-profit corporations. Arizona Republic,
June 14, 2009
"Operating [a closed-monitoring] institution with reduced and
inexperienced staffing in an effort to save money is not an option. To do so
puts public safety at risk."
Florida DOC Secretary Walt McNeil in letter to Florida Senate President Jeff
Atwater regarding a proposal to privatize a public close security prison.
Orlando-Sentinel, May 9, 2009
"The Monitoring Team has found that the lack of stable and effective
leadership at the vendor-level remains a concern."
Independent monitor regarding Correctional Medical Service's problems at the
Delaware Department of Corrections. News Journal, July 30, 2008
"They seem to be understaffed and they also
have a high (employee) turnover rate."
Attorney Mike Malloy about GEO's George Hill Correctional Facility. Newsof
DelawareCounty.com, December 30, 2004
"The (high turnover rate)
generally means that tenured staff is generally low, and when tenured staff is
very low, sometimes they have difficulties dealing with situations that are not
typical of everyday operations"
Colorado DOC's
director of prisons, Nolin Renfrow about CCA's Crowley prison's turnover. Pueblo
Chieftain, September 22, 2004
"But we still have a considerable amount of turnover. It's probably
in line with the rest of the industry. It's just the nature of the
business."
Securicor Facility Administrator Mike Smith on staff turnover at Florida's
Cypress Creek Juvenile Detention Facility. Citrus Chronicle, June 26,
2004
"When you're recruiting and training people as corrections officers, many
find when they're in training or in their first year that they aren't cut out as
corrections officers -- and opt out."
George Zoley, Wackenhut Corrections CEO after the death of Ralph Garcia at WCC's
Santa Rosa Facility. Garcia was making $7.89 an hour. Miami Herald, April
16, 2000
HIRING FORMER OFFICIALS
“The people who go back and forth come out really well, but
the taxpayers are the ones who aren’t well-served.”
New Mexico Sen. Cisco McSorley on former DOC Secretary Joe Williams returning to
GEO Group (formerly Wackenhut) where he worked before becoming NM DOC Secretary.
Williams refused to fine GEO and CCA for an estimated $18 million.
Albuquerque Journal, November 20, 2011
"I
personally don't see anything wrong with it."
Former Georgia Legislator turned CCA lobbyist Dan Lee about revolving door
politics. Atlanta Journal-Constitution, February 13, 2005
"The transition from legislator to lobbyist is just too
cozy right now."
Georgia Rep. Mary Margaret Oliver about former legislators using public
service for personal gain after leaving office. Atlanta Journal-Constitution,
February 13, 2005
"The revolving door is spinning so fast
it's now hit the department in the rear end.''
State Sen. Gloria Romero called for a
state audit of the deals last week after the Los Angeles Times reported that
Schwarzenegger's former finance director, Donna Arduin, was appointed to the
board of directors of a trust that owns the facility that GEO Group plans to use.
San Francisco Chronicle, February 4, 2005
"Most
companies want their lobbying teams to reflect the political landscape."
Chuck
McMullen, a former aide to Tom Price, the former Georgia majority leader newly
elected to the U.S. House, on CCA hiring the
former Georgia floor leader as a lobbyist. Atlanta Journal-Constitution,
January 14, 2005
“During the initial contract term, the contractor shall
not hire as an employee of contractor, any person who, at the time this contract
is executive, is serving in an elected office by the County of Dickson.”
Amendment to CCA proposed contract language after questions were raised over
possible hiring of Dickson County, Tennessee sheriff. Dickson Herald,
December 28, 2004
“I
think it’s vital that we have a direct line into the inner workings of that
process. From my perspective, this is something we really need to do.”
Reeves County, TX Judge Jimmy Galindo on hiring Randy DeLay, brother of U.S.
Rep. Tom DeLay, to lobby the federal Bureau of Prisons for inmates at the GEO
run county detention center. Odessa American, September 14, 2004
"We are not concerned. He is being retained because of his ability to be
kept up to speed with the decision making, like all of our lobbyists around the
states. That is why we retain the individual."
Steve Owens, CCA spokesman on hiring
David O'Leary, former CT Gov. chief of staff, under federal investigation into
bid-rigging and possible state impeachment charges. Record-Journal,
February 28, 2004
"This allows us to monitor ongoing public policy discussions in
corrections. Additionally, lobbyists provide an avenue by which the company can
inform and educate decision-makers of our industry generally and our company
specifically."
John Ferguson, CCA CEO on hiring Connecticut Gov. John Rowland's former chief of
staff. The Courant,
February 23, 2004
LIABILITY
"With the detention center, nothing has happened easy. It's been a
struggle for us all along, so, in some ways, we were not that surprised
that we've got a continued struggle."
Littlefield, TX, City Manager Danny Davis on news that the bid for his
empty prison formerly run by GEO fell through. KCBD, September
16, 2011
"The state doesn't contract away its responsibility."
Tom Rosazza, a consultant and former state corrections director on
Arizona's possible liability for three escapees from an MTC prison and
their brutal murder of two persons while on the run. Arizona Republic,
August 23, 2010
"It was their van, their employees driving the van, at a bare minimum
(G4S) should be offering compensation to the family."
Aboriginal Legal Service (Australia) director of legal services Peter
Collins on the government's payout of $3.2 million dollars to the family
of an aboriginal elder who roasted to death in the back of a Group 4
transport van. Group 4 has never apologized to the family. WA Today,
July 29, 2010
"Ultimately (Sheriff Joe Arpaio) is held accountable and responsible for
the health care provided the inmates in his jails."
Maricopa County (AZ) deputy chief MaryEllen Sheppard about the
county being on the hook for damages from its contract with private
medical provider Correctional Health Services. The Arizona Republic,
July 2, 2009
"Once you have a death or a serious injury in a jail, it will take you
five or six years to get through the litigation."
Gainesville (GA) City Attorney James E. "Bubba" Palmour advising against
the City from entering into an agreement with CCA, which offered
the city police department indemnification from any wrongdoing. Palmour
said no amount of indemnification would protect the city if a
"full-blown problem" arose at the facility. Gainesville Times,
May 14, 2009
“The county will always be named in the lawsuit. You can negotiate your
contract really well (but) the buck stops with the Commission anyways."
Steve Kopelman, New Mexico Association of Counties risk management
director to Curry County Commissioners on privatizing its jail.
Clovis News Journal, May 12, 2009
"However, they felt being administrators of the contract was putting the
county in a position where it could be ..... liable for a facility it does not
operate."
Williamson County, Texas spokeswoman Connie Watson on the county's move to end
its contract with CCA at the troubled T. Don Hutto Correctional Center. CBS
11TV, October 3, 2007
"Insurance companies still end up paying, but government officials still
find themselves spending time at depositions and trials. And the government is
still held accountable in the public eye. Privatization was supposed to wash the
stench of prisons off the government. But the stench is still there.''
New Mexico Attorney Mark Donnatlli on private prison liability. The New
Mexican, January 13, 2007
"You're not going to reduce lawsuits by changing the name over the door."
OSS Law Enforcement Advisors consultant David Salmon on privatization of
county jails. Sun Herald, August 21, 2006
"When government incarcerates someone, they have a responsibility to
ensure their safety"
Hernando County Florida Sheriff Richard Nugent on recent suicides at the
county's CCA jail. Hernando Today, January 25, 2006
"If a private company allows someone to get beat up or commit
suicide, I can guarantee you that the county would be named in that
lawsuit."
South Carolina Jail Administrators Association President Mark Fitzgibbons on
contracting away prison liability. Beaufort Gazette, November 12, 2005
"I get named in all the lawsuits at the jail. We already deal with
it to such a large extent that I think it's better we just have complete control
over it anyway, because we're the ones that have to answer for it. Private
companies aren't responsible to the public. We are."
Santa Fe County, New Mexico Sheriff Greg Solano on taking over jail
responsibility from Management and Training Corporation. Albuquerque Journal,
September 26, 2005.
"It's going to cost the state a lot of money in the long run."
Dr. Robert Cohen on state a federal lawsuits Delaware faces regardless of
Correctional Medical Services indemnification. Wilmington News Journal,
September 25, 2005.
"The
government still retains the responsibility for correctional services. The fact
that they outsource does not make them less responsible or less accountable.
They still have a contract to manage and they have oversight responsibility."
Mike LoBue, executive director of the Association of Private Correctional
Treatment Organizations. Yuma Sun,
April 3, 2005
''While
I understand the sheriff's position, and understand the health department's
position, you just can't contract away the city's responsibility.''
Kelvin
Jones, executive director of the Metro Human Relations Commission (Nashville,
Tennessee) on PHS health care issues. Tennessean, March 6, 2005
"The sheriff, and not the
defendant Lee County, has the responsibility to operate the Lee County Jail, and
funding by the county does not affect this responsibility."
U.S. District Judge John E. Steele
(Ft. Myers, FL) on sheriff's liability in PHS death suit at the Lee County Jail.
Naples Daily News, January 29, 2004
"Privatized
approaches to operation do not relieve the county of responsibility for jail
operations."
Jail consultant Howard Geisler on privatizing county jail. ZWire,
September 8, 2004
"I don't care what you do, the sheriff is still liable. There's no
way you can get out of it."
Indiana Sheriff's Association executive director Mike Eslinger on lawsuits
under jail privatization. Courier-Journal, August 17, 2004
"The state had a contractual obligation to oversee the contract with
these folks. The fact that you contract something out doesn't mean you wash your
hands of responsibility"
Bart Lubow of the Annie E. Casey Foundation on Maryland's lack of oversight
at CSC's Hickey School. Baltimore Sun, May 27, 2004
MANAGEMENT
"To have a prison that's chaotic, poorly run, dangerous,
didn't provide services, highly sexualized and highly violent really limits the
ability of the state to turn those folks around, and to ensure public safety
upon their release from prison."
Jonathan Smith, chief of special litigation in the civil rights section at the
Justice Department, about GEO's Walnut Grove Detention Center. NPR, April
24, 2012
"I just think it is ridiculous that a security company such as
Serco misjudges things so badly that prisoners are moved to and fro in black
taxis."
UK Home Secretary Theresa May on the use of taxis by Serco because their
computerized booking system failed. BBC, October 16, 2011
"If I make money doing it, I do it. If I don't make money, I
don't do it. It's a great business model."
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff's Major Michael Page on the one-year anniversary of
the Sheriff's take-over from CCA of the jail. St Petersburg Times, August
28, 2011
"If they (CCA) had performed routine maintenance as they
should have and as their contract required, this building would look 10 times
better."
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff's Major Michael Page on the one-year anniversary of
the Sheriff's take-over from CCA of the jail. St Petersburg Times, August
28, 2011
"There were clear indicators (that Villawood staff advise were
present at the time) that the riots were reasonably foreseeable. Despite the
apparent clear indications, no critical incident plans were in place for staff
to follow, should such a situation occur."
A wide-ranging report delivered by Comcare, the Federal Government's (Australia)
workplace safety agency. ABC, August 11, 2011
"We are getting fined for things that should have been
completed. We are getting fined for not paying attention to the detail. We are
getting fined for not doing what we have said we will do."
Serco's senior operations manager for the detention centre, Steve Southgate,
addressed colleagues about continued breaches at their Christmas Island . The
Australian, July 13, 2011
"It was supposed to be a fail-safe to let the prison know that the guy
shouldn't be let go."
Delaware Co (PA) Deputy District Attorney Daniel McDevitt on learning that yet
another CEC inmate was "accidentally" released even after his office sent a fax
weeks before warning not to release this inmate.
Philadelphia Daily News, September 3, 2010
"Public safety is county council’s top priority and we won’t tolerate
mistakes when it comes to our criminal justice system and the safety of our
residents."
Delware County (PA) council Chairman Jack Whelan on "accidental" releases from
Correctional Educational Centers' George W. Hill prison. Delco Times,
September 1, 2010
"Our goal is, we don't want them to come back. The way CCA was running
it, why wouldn't you want to come
back?"
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on taking over the jail from CCA.
Hernando Today, August 27, 2010
"You need to do a more thorough search. The bottom line is, you are
responsible when you open the back door."
Delco County
(PA) Superintendent John Reilly Jr., who oversees CEC's performance on the
county's behalf, on the recent "accidental" release of inmates at the George W.
Hill Prison. Philadelphia Daily News, August 27, 2010
"They're pretty much doing what they want there while they stay within
the walls."
Hernando County (FL) Maj. Michael Page, the county jail's new administrator on
how lax CCA was on inmates at the jail. St Petersburg Times, August 22,
2010
"We are going over everything that happened during the night of the
escape, and many issues will be addressed with MTC."
Arizona DOC spokesman Barrett Marson on how three convicted murderers escaped
from MTC's Arizona State Prison in Kingman. AP, August 3, 2010
"A number of staff reported feeling unsupported by managers, detainees
claimed that some staff were bullied by more difficult detainees."
Chief Inspector of Prisons
(UK) Dame Anne Owers on report about Group 4 run Brook House detention prison.
The Guardian, July 12, 2010
“I think that they have perfunctory meetings that don’t result in any
significant change."
Vermont Defender General Matthew Valerio, who oversees the prisoners’ rights
office, said his office regularly gets complaints about the lack of education,
work or recreation programs and concerns about racial tensions between inmates
at CCA's West Tennessee Detention Facility. The Rutland Herald, June 29,
2010
"The department is committed to ensuring that federal contractors and
subcontractors hire, promote and compensate their employees fairly, without
respect to their race, gender, ethnicity, disability, religion or veteran
status."
Patricia A. Shiu, director of the U.S. Department of Labor's Office of Federal
Contract Compliance Programs on a $290,000 discrimination settlement with
Wackenhut/Group 4. Department of Labor Press Release, June 9, 2010
"Both the lack of the jailer licenses by the warden and deputy warden,
the lack of properly or entirely filling out the inmate screening form, and
failing to report the April 18, 2010, death in custody within 24 hours as
required will immediately result in a notice of non-compliance with minimum jail
standards for the Coastal Bend Detention Center."
Robstown commission Director Adan Muñoz on Louisiana Corrections Services
failure to meet state standards at is Coastal Bend Correctional Facility.
Caller-Times, May 3, 2010
"We talked to the sheriff; he made a proposal. It was the best move we ever
made. It's been like night and day. I haven't had a phone call on the jail in
the two years since he took over."
Bay County (FL) Commissioner Mike Nelson on taking the jail away from CCA and
giving it to the Sheriff.
Hernando Today, March 3, 2010
"They were threatening to riot again - so the bosses called in an IT man.
He credited all the accounts with a fiver, so everyone could phone home."
An insider at Kalyx's (Sodexho's) Addiewell Prison (Scotland) about paying-off
the inmates not to riot in response to an issue with their phone accounts.
The Sun, February 17, 2010
"Unfortunately, private prisons are run to
make a profit. Ultimately, the company in charge of them has to deliver for
their shareholders and so they have to find ways to make money. The way to do
this is by having fewer staff, paying low wages, investing less money in
training and pensions, and this impacts on the running of the prison. For a
prison to run properly, you need the guards and the prisoners to understand each
other and work with each other, and that requires experienced guards. That takes
an investment in training and keeping staff, which can be at odds with the need
to deliver a profit."
Former Chief Inspector of Prisons (Scotland) Sir Clive Fairweather on the cause
of a riot at the Kalyx (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. Edinburgh Evening News,
January 28, 2010
"Litre bottles of spirits aren't the sort of thing you can send in with a
letter or hand over at a visit. He must be having them brought in by someone
working at the prison."
Scottish prison official after a killer was caught drunk with bottles of vodka
at Kalyx's Addiewell Prison. Sunday Mail, January 10, 2010
“Certainly an improperly released inmate is a liability to all parties
involved.”
Adan Muñoz, the Texas jail commission’s executive director after an undocumented
immigrant mistakenly was released from an LCS prison and went un-noticed for
three weeks. Caller-Times, December 18, 2009
“We hope the report will detail what really happened .”
Head of (GEO Group) prison security Nyiko Mathebula on figuring out how two
dangerous criminals escaped from GEO's Kutama Sinthumule Correctional Centre,
Limpopo. Sowatan, December 17, 2009
"We went on to check the recreation log to see if their concerns were
valid. We couldn't even find a recreation log."
Adan Munoz, executive director of the Texas Commission on Jail Standards on
trying to verify claims that inmates are not getting recreation time at
Southwestern Correction's Burnet County Jail. KVAN, October 20,
2009
“I have to bring any remedial order before the (jail) commission, but
this borders really close to complete incompetence.”
Texas Commission on Jail Standards commission Director Adan Muñoz on conditions
inside LCS's Coastal Bend Detention Center after it was cited for failing to
classify inmates, check for contraband, improper staff training, jailers without
proper state licensing and no tuberculosis screening plan, among other issues.
Corpus Christi Caller-Times, September 21, 2009
"Mr Westcott's death was not … without sufficient warning as to render
his death unpreventable. I find a direct correlation between the failure of the
intercom system and Mr Westcott's death."
Australian Coroner Audrey Jamieson on the death of an inmate at a Group 4
prison. Ian Thomas Campbell Westcott was found dead after suffering an asthma
attack. The intercom system did not work. Herald Sun, July 9, 2009
"Without a doubt, there is a breakdown somewhere."
Steven Owen of Corrections Corporation of America, the company that operates the
Mississippi prison where an inmate escaped during a medical appointment and shot
a Tennessee Trooper. WSMV, June 26, 2009
"If these issues are being repeated
that's a matter of great concern, because this is not rocket science."
Former head of Queensland's corrective services, Keith Hamburger, on the death
of a tribal elder in a prisoner transport van years after a scathing report on
Global Solutions (now Group 4) management. Four Corners, June 15, 2009
"It wasn't what we were after. It wasn't what I would have expected."
Vermont Department of Corrections Commissioner Andrew Pallito on pulling his
state's inmates from LCS's Perry County
Correctional Center in Alabama because of lack of response to concerns
over security and inadequately trained staff. Bennington Banner, June 9,
2009
"We're concerned a driver doing 102mph claims to be unaware of his speed
– what sort of message does this put out to other road users? A man who makes
his income from speed cameras should know better."
Claire Armstrong, of the Safe Speed campaign group (UK) about Tom Riall,
CEO of Serco. who was caught speeding by his companies own cameras. The
Telegraph, May 4, 2009
"I'm very excited and proud with quality and cost-effectiveness of OCC. I
had great confidence in our medical care partners in the community and that we
could do what we set out to do. I think the OCC model is now a bona fide model
for others."
Marion County (FL) Sheriff Dean on replacing Prison Health Services with a local
non-profit coalition to provide medical care at the county jail. Ocala
Star-Banner, February 7, 2009
"There's a history of problems at that facility."
Attorney Ryan Barack representing a former CCA guard in a sexual harassment suit
against CCA's Hernando County (FL) Jail. Hernando Today, January 16, 2009
"Every time the issue comes up, CCA acts like it's never been raised
before."
Bay County (FL) Deputy Public Defender Walter Smith on CCA's consistently not
producing clothing for inmates headed to trial. News-Herald,
September 3, 2008
"Our feeling is they have not met our requirements for quality care at
the jail."
Dr. Fred Miller, Pima County's (AZ) chief medical officer on the cancelling
of CMS' contract at the county jail.
Arizona Daily Star, July 2, 2008
"I'm not going to tell you there will never be a hostage situation or
jail break or issues in jail but I will tell you that there will be far less
than what CCA has had to deal with in that facility downtown."
Bay County Florida, Sheriff Frank McKeithen on agreeing to take over management
of the Bay County Jail from CCA. WMBB, June 3, 2008
"We have certain standards regarding foods for inmates that we're not
prepared to see relaxed. We want to make sure they jibe with our standards."
Florida Department of Corrections Chief of Staff Richard Prudom said of Aramark
after assessing nearly $250,000 in fines against the company. Palm Beach Post,
May 12, 2008
“It might be more realistic to empty the centre briefly, so that it can
be relaunched with a properly trained and reinvigorated staff, focused on plenty
of good-quality, purposeful activity, dynamic security, and an emphasis on
appropriate behaviour within clear boundaries.”
Anne Owers, UK Chief Inspector of Prisons, suggestion to close the jail after
finding a lack of control and order at
Group 4's Oakhill Secure Training Unit. The Times, March 17, 2008
“I think it was yesterday morning, I said, ‘By the way, you all did take
out your warrant didn’t you?’ And that’s what triggered them to go do it. They
should have done that right away. We would have done that, I think, right away.”
Davidson County Tennessee Sheriff Daron Hall on why it took CCA two days
before getting a warrant issues for an escapee from their Metro Davidson County
Detention Center. WSMV, February 20, 2008
"The rule appears to be at this point, you can't have a blanket policy.
You would think that prison officials would be aware of it and would be
careful."
David Rudovsky, a University of Pennsylvania law professor on an inmate being
strip-searched at GEO's George W. Hill Correctional Facility in Pennsylvania on
a misdemeanor charges. AP, January 31, 2008
"Evidently when she went through the metal detector, it didn't go off, or
she got it past the guard that searched her clothing items."
Kentucky state police detective Mike Goble after a CCA employee committed
suicide at the Otter Creek Correctional Facility. Honolulu Advertiser,
January 26, 2008
"A depressing picture has been painted of Rye Hill Prison, of the
availability of drugs within the prison and of low morale among inmates and
prison officers."
U.K. Judge Richard Bray on sentencing a Global Solutions guard to prison for
smuggling drugs into the Rye Hill Prison. BBC, December 11, 2007
"My hope is they are doing all that is necessary to determine what
happened and how it can be prevented from happening again."
John Reilly, who, as acting superintendent, oversees the GEO Group's
performance at the George W. Hill Correctional Facility on the recent firing of
GEO's troubled warden. Philadelphia Daily News,
December 1, 2007
"The issue here is a poor management climate, and it stems directly from
his deficiencies as a warden."
John Reilly, the acting superintendent and top Delaware County official
referring to GEO's George W. Hill Correctional Facility. Philadelphia Daily News,
November 29, 2007
“This is a jail, and it needs to be run like one. It shouldn’t have
happened; I don’t want it to ever happen again.”
Bay County, Florida Commissioner Mike Nelson on recent accidental release of
four inmates from CCA's Bay County Jail. News Herald, November
20, 2007
“That kind of carelessness is something we can’t have. I mean, they’re
running a jail.”
Bay County, Florida Commissioner Mike Nelson on recent accidental
release of four inmates from CCA's Bay County Jail. News Herald, November
14, 2007
"There was some evidence that violent incidents were not consistently
followed up or investigated, which led to prisoners stating that they, rather
than the staff, were in control of the units."
UK Chief Inspector of Prisons Anne Owers on a report on Global Solutions Rye
Hill Prison. The Guardian,
October 9, 2007
"The reasons ICE left may or not be found in documents or specific numbers.
It may simply be a feeling, which they have expressed."
Cornell spokesman Charles Seigel on why ICE pulled its detainees from the
Regional Correctional Center in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Albuquerque Tribune,
September 25, 2007
"We let our guard down. . . . We weren't complying."
John M. Hurley, a GEO vice president
on a report about contraband, drugs, etc. in their Lawrenceville
Correctional Facility in Virginia.
Times-Dispatch, September 12, 2007
"However, if we had operated RCC as we do our best facilities, no one would
have had any basis for criticism. But we didn't."
Cornell Chairman and CEO James Hyman
on Cornell's Regional Correctional Center in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
Albuquerque Tribune, August 11, 2007
“They’re masters at telling you what you want to hear, and then when their
butts in the crack, they renege on it”
Hernando County, Florida Sheriff Richard Nugent on CCA's lack of
forthrightness regarding paying for inmate fingerprinting. Hernando Today,
March 27, 2007
"You expect a little better communication and a little better adherence to
the contract then what we're getting out of CCA"
Bay County Florida Commissioner George Gainer on CCA's hiring a new warden
without consulting with the county even though its required by the contract.
NEWS 13, February 6, 2007
"I think it's pretty universal."
Wyoming health services administrator Anne Cybulski-Sandlian on the bad press
Prison Health Services earned.
Star-Tribune, September 19, 2005
"Melbourne
Custody Centre is mismanaged through and through."
GEO correctional officer Bruna Moressi. Herald Sun
November 18, 2004
"Our capital is being wasted here,
and our company is being undermanaged. We are not going to let you guys destroy
this company. Your time at Cornell is limited."
Zachary George with Pirate Capital, a Connecticut hedge fund that owns 7.5
percent of Cornell's shares.
Houston Chronicle, August 15, 2004
MISLEADING INFORMATION
"This is an absolute distraction, put out to tell people not
to even worry about it."
Former prison chaplain and RMIT (Australia) adjunct professor Peter Norden on
the government's response blaming a recent riot at GEO's Fulham Correctional
Center on toothbrushes and loss of pay TV. The Australian, January 20,
2012
"With the detention center, nothing has happened easy. It's been a struggle
for us all along, so, in some ways, we were not that surprised that we've got a
continued struggle."
Littlefield, TX, City Manager Danny Davis on news that the bid for his empty
prison formerly run by GEO fell through. KCBD, September 16, 2011
"There were some things promised to Hardin I think, but those people who
promised them are no longer on the scene. So, now what?"
Tow Rivers Authority (MT) board member Bill Joseph on a misleading feasibility
study by Municipal Capital Markets that left the Two Rivers Detention Center
sitting empty and the bonds in default. KULR 8, November 17, 2009
"Several times accepted the promises made by the company management, but
it seems to be a strategy to buy time and not pay the money owed to workers."
Castigo Meque, from the Union of Private Security Companies (Mozambique) on
Group 4 owing workers overtime payments that had been promised. All Africa,
August 13, 2009
"There is nothing in the record supporting GEO's patently untrue
statements of material fact and omission of material fact, in the documents
filed with the SEC."
Attorney Ronald Rodriguez in court papers filed against GEO regarding
misinformation about a wrongful death suit settlement. Brownsville Herald
,
July 6, 2009
“The understanding Council had was that it would a minimum security type
facility house people awaiting deportation. Now we’re not so sure.”
Gainesville (GA) City Manager Kip Padgett about his Council’s understanding that
CCA would be running a minimum-security facility for illegal aliens at the
Gainesville Jail instead of the felons CCA plans to bring in. Access
North GA, March 25, 2009
"I would call every so often and talk to the counselor. And she always
said, 'Well he's doing OK.'"
Frank Horton's grandmother Mary Braswell about
CCA inmate Horton being left in solitary confinement for over nine months
without a shower or coming out because prison officials refused to forcibly
remove him. NewsChannel 5, October 30, 2008
“Contractual payments for services rendered.”
CCA's argument that the money it receives from governmental contracts are
not "funds" and therefore they are not subject to public records requests under
Tennessee law.
Tennessean, July 31, 2008
"This is realistic. That was unrealistic."
Bay County (Florida) Commissioner Bill Dozier said of the sheriff's numbers for
running the Bay County Jail seemed right, as opposed to CCA's . News-Herald,
June 3, 2008
"Instead of facing the issue head-on, there's all kinds of games and
machinations and denials."
John Reilly, who, as acting
superintendent, oversees the GEO Group's performance at the George W. Hill
Correctional Facility on the finding of a racist photograph of GEO's guard
union's president with a noose around her neck. Philadelphia Daily News,
December 1, 2007
"The supervisors have authorized me to take whatever action is necessary.
We have even talked about eminent domain proceedings."
Morris Township, Pennsylvania, Solicitor F. Cortez Bell on Cornell reneging
on its agreements with the township. Centre Daily Times, January 15, 2007
"We feel that a change order from an existing contract does not ensure
the benefit of the 3 percent. The contract to build a new prison is not a change
order or an existing contract. The contractor owes us the 4.5 percent."
Eloy, Arizona City Manager Jim McFellin on CCA's attempt to avoid paying the
city higher taxes it agreed to. Casa Grande Dispatch, December 21, 2006
"They said they could help us on the second project if we gave them the
third project, but now that they got the contract for the third project, they
threw the second project back at us saying it is not their responsibility."
Willacy County, Texas District Attorney Juan Guerra on how the county was
sold private prisons. Killeen Daily Herald, November 13, 2006
"This was a serious mistake, and a boondoggle of
the nth degree. They sold it to us, and it didn't meet code."
Wisconsin Sen. Fred Risser on his states purchase of a Dominion prison in
Stanley, Wisconsin.
Journal-Sentinel,
May 17, 2006
"We're not sure that we could get a clear title, because it's part
of a $715 million loan package, with 32 other CCA facilities. We got out-lawyered.
The contract is slanted toward CCA. Their lawyers wrote it in their best
interest and the state's lawyers didn't catch it. The lawyers for the state who
reviewed the original contract did a very poor job."
Montana State Senator Jim Shockley on CCA's contract for the Crossroads CC
in Shelby, Montana. Shelby Promoter, January 26, 2005
“I asked how many
times do you expect law enforcement will have to come out there (to
Southern Peaks), and he said ‘oh, once or twice a year.’ Well, they
filled that quota in the first couple hours.”
Fremont County, Colorado Sheriff Jim Beicker on Cornell's assurances
that the public would have little trouble from their Southern Peaks
Treatment Facility. Canyon Cafe, October 8, 2004
"They reviewed the profit-and-loss statements
for the two fiscal years between July 2000 and June 2002. But the information
provided by Cornell was not adequate to determine if the center was being
operated efficiently."
Valencia County, NM Manager Mike Trujillo. Albuquerque
Journal, September 22, 2004
"We as a county would like to see a stronger commitment on behalf of
Cornell - we evidently were mislead a little, too."
Aurora County Chairman Oscar Thompson on Cornell's attempt to get more money
for its State Training School in Plankinton, South Dakota. Daily Republic,
August 5, 2004
NEGLECT
“It is always disappointing to chart a decline in the performance of a
prison but, sadly, that is the case with this inspection of HMP Wolds."
Dame Anne Owers, Chief Inspector of Prisons (UK) on a report that
condemns Group 4's Wolds Prison.
The Independent, July 6, 2010
"These are children we are talking about. It is unacceptable that they
are detained at all."
Donna Covey, chief executive of the Refugee Council (UK) about a report
on the treatment of children at Serco's Yarl's Wood prison. InTheNews,
February 17, 2010
"I suspect they now know that in all likelihood they would not win the
bid again."
Vermont Corrections Commissioner Andrew Pallito on Ashley Ellis' dethd
from cardiac problems that the Vermont Medical Examiner concluded
Wednesday were complicated by the "denial of access to medication."
Rutland Herald, October 1, 2009
"The treatment that Aleksey received during the period he was at Rye Hill
was both appalling and at times unacceptable."
Assistant deputy coroner for Northamptonshire (UK) Tom Osbourne on the
susicide of an inmate at Global's (now Group 4) Rye Hill prison. BBC,
September 23, 2009
"I find that the failure of the intercom system denied Mr Westcott the
opportunity to receive medical attention."
Australian Coroner Audrey Jamieson on the death of an inmate at a Group
4 prison. Ian Thomas Campbell Westcott was found dead after suffering an
asthma attack. The intercom system did not work. Herald Sun, July
9, 2009
"There's many times we have been sat by the side of the road broken down.
Sometimes 15, 20-odd hours those vehicles have been stuck out in the
middle of nowhere, broken down, with prisoners on board and without
prisoners on board. Those vehicles were untrustworthy."
Group 4 driver Nina Stokoe after being sacked by the company over the
death a an Australian tribal elder who cooked to death in the back of a
Group 4 van. Brisbane Times, June 23, 2009
"I witnessed some pretty bad injuries when I was in Taft there. Guys
falling over, one guy broke his femur, another broke his hip, one guy
was punched in the face and he had glass embedded in his eye and it took
him about a day before they finally took him to the doctor, at
Bakersfield, in the hospital. It was horrid."
Convicted former Rep. Vic Kohring (AK) on his stay at the Taft Correctional
Institution (CA) run by MTC.
Anchorage Daily-News, June 13, 2009
"That's the downside of the private-run facility. There was a certain
amount of indifference there."
Convicted former Rep. Vic Kohring (AK) on his stay at the Taft
Correctional Institution (CA) run by MTC.
Anchorage Daily-News,
June 13, 2009
“In hindsight, if I had to do that journey again, I would certainly be
doing it a lot differently.”
Global Solutions Limited driver Graham Powell said he regretted how Mr
Ward an Aboriginal elder died of heat stroke while being transported
across the Outback. The West, March 21, 2009
"He literally starved. We watched him turn into a skeleton."
William Morris Byrd Jr.'s sister Charlotte Boyd, about the lack of care
by Wexford . Her brother died after months of wasting away at Central
Mississippi Correctional Facility in Pearl. Clarion Ledger,
December 2, 2008
"An immigration removal centre can never be a suitable place for children
and we were dismayed to find cases of disabled children being detained
and some children spending large amounts of time incarcerated."
Report by the UK Inspectorate of Prisons on the conditions at Serco's
Yarl's Wood Detention Center. BBC,
August 22, 2008
"They do not have a clear idea or philosophy of their approach to health
care [for detainees]. "It's a system failure, not a failure of
individuals."
Neil Sampson, who ran the DIHS as interim director most of 2007 in an
interview on ICE treated detainee health care. Washington Post,
May 11, 2008
"Now enters GEO with their paid lobbyists attempting to put a good face
on this. I'm saying the corporation should back
off. They've run a very poor facility that probably violates the youths'
civil rights. ... Kids were stepping in their own feces. The sheets were
such that a cat or dog wouldn't sleep on them."
Texas State Senator John Whitmire on conditions at GEO's Coke County
Juvenile Justice Center. Dallas Morning News, October 5, 2007
"This is certainly a situation that we want to understand how it
happened."
CMS spokesman Ken Fields trying to explain how a woman gave birth in
her Maryland detention center cell without medical support. The Capital,
December 1, 2005
"Something certainly went
wrong, the man died."
Palm Beach County, Florida Circuit
Judge Jeffrey Winikoff on Prison Health Services claiming it wasn't responsible
for the death of an inmate at the Palm Beach County Jail. Palm Beach Post,
September 16, 2005
''I don't see this is just a weird coincidence. I
see this is a pattern based on other information I'm seeing.''
Nashville attorney David Raybin on PHS' consistent medical problems at the Metro
Jail. Tennessean, February 1, 2005
"Hourly
prisoner checks were not conducted or documented and shift change counts were
not conducted or documented according to the state standards."
Oklahoma
Jail Inspection Division report on inmate death at CCA's jail in Tulsa. Tulsa
World, January 9, 2005
"In
correctional health care you treat the symptoms. For example if an inmate has an
abscessed tooth. We do not have to fix it, but we do have to treat the
symptoms"
Union County Sheriff Steve Leverton on Advanced Correctional Services
contract for the jail. News Examiner, December 31, 2004
"I had to intervene in may cases of men who were neglected."
Former nurse Theresa McAvinney on lack of care by CMS at the North State CF
in Newport, VT.
WCAX Channel 3 News, July 29,
2004
OVERSIGHT
"And to add one final insult to these injuries, State
officials repeatedly failed to monitor the contracts with GEO and simply
rewarded the company by either extending or offering new contracts, or
by not revoking the existing contract despite 'systemic, egregious, and
dangerous practices exacerbated by a lack of accountability and
controls."
U.S. District Judge Carlton Reeves in his settlement order against the
State of Mississippi for its role at GEO's Walnut Grove Correctional
Facility. Sun Herald, March 29, 2012
"We have three monitors now. We could have six there
and not see everything."
Idaho Department of Corrections Director Brent Reinke on CCA's violent
Idaho Correctional Center. AP,
October 9, 2011
"It is critical that the state takes a more active role in ensuring the
success of these programs. It cannot simply cut these halfway houses a
check and hope for the best."
New Jersey State Comptroller Matthew Boxer
about the Department of Corrections not enforcing contracts with
providers. NJ 101.5, June 15, 2011
"There are likely to be
significant risk to health and safety associated with the relocation of
the Christmas Island detainees to the Villawood IDF."
A safety order issues by Comcare less than three weeks before a riot at
the Serco Villawood (Ausralia) prison.
The Daily Telegraph, June 3, 2011
“So the list of items that
could qualify as a breach of the contract are not public, and the
department doesn’t audit the list of breaches — what breaches happen,
how many breaches happen — at what stage is there any type of
transparency?”
Australian Senator Hanson-Young on not only is the $1 billion
contract awarded to detention centre operator Serco beyond the reach of
public scrutiny, but Senate Estimates hearings today revealed that the
Department of Immigration and Citizenship collects scant data on
breaches and has limited knowledge and oversight of staff training
levels. TangataWhenua.com, May 30, 2011
“The jury found that not only have the promises noted above not been
achieved, some of the conditions of the contract have apparently not
been met."
Santa Barbara County (CA) Grand Jury report on Prison Health Services
not meeting its obligations. Noozhawk,
May 26, 2011
"We'd like to follow up and perhaps do a performance group review on the
private prison operators to see whether they are making excessive
profits."
New Mexicao Rep. Luciano "Lucky" Varela justifying the state not fining
CCA and GEO for staffing vacancies.
New Mexican, April 25, 2011
"There's no legitimate reason why our private prisons shouldn't be held
to the same standards as public prisons."
Arizona House Minority Leader Chad Campbell who is sponsoring five bills
on oversight for private prisons but can't get a hearing because of the
influence the vendors have over the legislature. Arizona Republic,
February 15, 2011
"I believe it is obvious that the contract has not been complied with and
that Aramark is in substantial breach of it."
Kentucky Rep. Brent Yonts calling for an investigation into Aramark's
contract. Lexington Herald-Leader,
January 10, 2011
“It’s real bothersome to me that we’re scratching for money and he
unilaterally makes this decision. That is spending taxpayer money
recklessly. He is not looking out for the best interest of New Mexico.”
New Mexico Sen. John Arthur Smith, chairman of the Senate Finance
Committee,
on DOC Secretary
Joe Williams, former GEO warden, not penalizing up to $18 M against GEO
and CCA for vacancies. New Mexico Independent, September 21, 2010
"NMCD does not regularly compile vacancy rates, contractor staff pay
rates, contractor vacancy savings or review potential penalty amount in
its central office, but should do so immediately."
New Mexico Legislative Finance Committee on DOC Secretary Joe Williams,
former GEO warden, not overseeing contracts with GEO and CCA. New
Mexico Independent, September 15, 2010
"The contract
does not say I shall do it. The contract says I can do it."
New Mexico DOC Secretary Joe Williams on why he didn't deduct vacancy
penalties against his former employer GEO Group (Wackenhut) and CCA.
New Mexico Independent, September 2, 2010
"The
private-prison industry lobbied heavily against that bill, and they were
successful."
Michael Haener, Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano's lobbyist at the time
CCA killed a bill that would have put oversight on the industry.
Arizona Republic, August 22, 2010
"I would say they weren't doing their job."
Kentucky Rep. Brent Yonts on the state's lack of oversight and
enforcement of liquidated damages against CCA. Courier-Journal,
July 5, 2010
“We are scrambling to do that due diligence with the aim of getting them
licensed so they can proceed. So we’re kind of behind the eight-ball on
this.”
Laura Blondeau, spokeswoman for Minister Rick Bartolucci, Ministry of
Community Safety and Correctional Services (Canada) on finding out
company providing security for the G20 summit, Contemporary Security
Canada, wasn't licensed to do business in Ontario. The Globe and Mail,
June 8, 2010
"We're very concerned. That's the whole purpose of the audit, to find
these things before they get to a level where they're critical."
Rona Siegert,
director of Idaho Department of Correction Health Services, on CCA
having problems with drug and alcohol treatment and medical care at the
Idaho Correctional Center. AP, June 1, 2010
"Apparently, there had been complaints for years about the quality of the
food, the portion sizes and the continual shortage and substitutions for
scheduled menu items. Sanitation of the kitchen was also a source of
complaints."
Investigation report into the riot at Kentucky's Northpoint Training
Center citing Aramark food as one of the contributing factors into the
riot. Herald-Leader, January 28, 2010
“The rampant problems of medical and mental health care aren’t just going
to go away if there’s more oversight.”
David Shapiro, a lawyer with the A.C.L.U.’s National Prison Project, on
immigrant deaths at detention facilities. New York Times, August
21, 2009
"Our nation’s immigration detention system has been plagued by a total
lack of transparency and accountability, and even with today’s
announcement there is no way we can be fully confident that there are
not still more deaths that somehow have gone unaccounted for.”
David Shapiro, staff lawyer with the A.C.L.U. National Prison Project on
news that more than one in 10 deaths in immigration detention in the
last six years have been overlooked and were omitted from an official
list of detainee fatalities issued to Congress in March. New York
Times, August 17, 2009
"If these issues are being repeated that's a matter of great concern,
because this is not rocket science."
Former head of Queensland's corrective services, Keith Hamburger, on the
death of a tribal elder in a prisoner transport van years after a
scathing report on Global Solutions (now Group 4) management. Four
Corners, June 15, 2009
"It was a real loose outfit. There have been some real problems there."
Vermont State Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Dick Sears on LCS'
operation of the Perry County Correctional Center in Alabama after VT
removed its inmates. Bennington Banner, June 9, 2009
"A significant number of complaints, including allegations of staff
bullying, were not adequately investigated and replies lacked detail."
Anne Owers, the Chief Inspector of Prisons (UK) about a report on
Serco's Colnbrook Immigration Removal Centre. The Independent,
June 2, 2009
"My concern relates to inmate safety at ICC resulting from the increased
violence in recent months."
Former Virtual Prison Program Warden Randy Blades (ID) about concerns
over CCA not fully investigating cases of inmate-on-inmate violence and
weren't reporting major inmate crimes to the Ada County Sheriff's office
for investigation and prosecution. The Olympian, April 4, 2009
"With so many people languishing in immigration detention, it is shameful
that the Home Secretary refused to investigate these very serious
allegations of mistreatment."
Anna Fairclough, legal officer at Liberty, a human rights group after
the courts rules that there should have been an investigation into
immigrant abuse at Kalyx's Harmondsworth Immigration Detention Centre
(UK). Worthing Herald, March 17, 2009
"Right now, with these jails there is no accountability, no regulation,
no oversight."
Missouri Sen. David Pearce on his bill requiring private prisons and jails
to report escapes after two inmates escaped from a private jail at about
5 a.m. but the sheriff's office was not notified until 1 p.m. that day,
and local residents were not informed until even later. Columbia
Missourian, March 13, 2009
"The audit felt like we were giving too many warnings to private prisons
and that we needed to start doing more liquidated damages."
Oklahoma DOC Director Justin Jones on the state's recent fining of CCA
and GEO Group for inadequate staffing at their facilities. Tulsa
World, December 16, 2008
“I told them at the end of it, ‘If it were my decision I’d fire you.'"
Metro-Davidson County Councilman Michael Craddock on meetings with
Wackenhut (Group 4) over the break-in and stealing of a sensitive
computer and the overbilling by Wackenhut. Nashville City Paper,
December 10, 2008
"This really just points to what we had in our report, that there's no
oversight over these detention centers, and contractors can get away
with all kinds of things."
Pramila Jayapal, executive director of OneAmerica, on GEO Group's
falsifying guard background checks. AP,
September 30, 2008
"The Monitoring Team has found that the lack of stable and effective
leadership at the vendor-level remains a concern."
Independent monitor regarding Correctional Medical Service's problems at
the Delaware Department of Corrections. News Journal, July 30,
2008
"The fact the chief inspector made the recommendation three years ago and
nothing has been done since is down to the Home Office. "
Norman McLean, head of the Independent Monitoring Board Secretariat
(UK), after learning that nothing had been done in three years to
increase oversight at private immigrant detention centers. Daily Mail,
June 15, 2008
“This is outrageous that this is going on, and that nothing appears to
being done about it.”
Scott Medlock, attorney for the Texas Civil Rights Project in
Austin, about the lack of oversight regarding allegations of sexual
abuse of detainees at GEO's South Texas Detention Complex.
WOAI, May 16, 2008
"No WDOC Policy, Procedure or Directive is in place that requires the
tracking and compliance of out of state incidents to ensure that these
incident (sic) are properly tracked for compliance."
Maj. William Moore of the Wyoming Department of Corrections in a report
about an inmate beating at CCA's Oklahoma North Fork Correctional
Facility. Casper Star-Tribune, February 19, 2008
“The Department of Corrections is not responsible for the collections.
The matter is ultimately an issue between OPM and CCA.”
DC DOC spokesperson Beverly Young on the city's lack of ability to collect
an estimated $7.5 million owed it by CCA because two agencies are
pointing fingers at each other.
Washington City Papers, February 15, 2008
"This contract has been running for over 10 years, and we were not
provided a single monitoring report."
National Commission on Correctional Health Care on lack of oversight by
the Michigan Department of Corrections over its contract with
Correctional Medical Services. Detroit News, January 23, 2008
"There has been little oversight of this program, and self-reporting has
allowed Wackenhut to operate without accountability and in relative
anonymity."
Milwaukee County Sheriff David A. Clarke Jr. calling for an audit of
Wackenhut Corp., claiming the company is doing a poor job despite its
nearly $1 million-a-year contract to provide security on county bus
routes. Journal Sentinel, December 19, 2007
"Even if you excuse the inexcusable – which is not knowing from the
beginning that this guy was a registered sex offender – there were
complaints that were filed that should have put them on notice long,
long before he was terminated."
Dallas lawyer Bob Crill over GEO's hiring a registered sex offender as a
guard at the Coke County Juvenile Justice Center. Dallas Morning News,
December 6, 2007
“I want to know exactly what happens to these officers and have got an
appointment to see G4. I want to know how prisons can operate
functionally if there are no records kept on officers disciplined. They
can then go and get a job elsewhere."
Shadow Welsh Secretary Cheryl Gillan on discrepancies in Group 4's
records regarding fired guards. Wales on Sunday, December
2, 2007
"It pains me to think of all the people who have been mistreated
there in the years since we first raised the issue. If the authorities
had listened to us, then all that suffering could have been avoided."
Former Melbourne Custody Center employee Ros
Atkinson on how her information on abuse was ignored by GEO Group and
others. The Herald Sun, November 24, 2007
"We told the company, we told the Ombudsman, we told Victoria Police, we
told members of Parliament, and others, but the situation didn't
improve."
Former Melbourne Custody Center employee Ros Atkinson on how her
information on abuse was ignored by GEO Group and others. The Herald
Sun, November 24, 2007
"The private prison contractor and the Government have a common interest
in burying the issues."
Hugh de Kretser, executive officer of the Federation of Community Legal
Centres on the difficulty in getting access to information a private
prisons and jails in Australia. The Age, November 24, 2007
"The MCC appears to operate with only limited oversight by both GEO and
Victoria Police and in my opinion the system in place to monitor
incidents is unsatisfactory."
Victorian Ombudsman George Brouwer on a beating of a detainee at
GEO's Melbourne Custody Center. The Age, November 22, 2007
“What concerns me is what else is going on out there that we don’t know
about.”
Bay County, Florida Commissioner Mike Nelson on recent
accidental release of four inmates from CCA's Bay County Jail. News Herald, November
20, 2007
“Managing prisoners out of state, quite frankly, is very, very difficult for
us.”
Colorado Department of Corrections Director Ari Zavaras on shipping inmates
to a CCA prison in Oklahoma. Daily Sentinel, October 15, 2007
"It was very simple that the monitors were not doing their job and there
was a human failure. Who's monitoring the monitors?"
Texas State Sen. John Whitmire on the lack of oversight of GEO's troubled Coke County Juvenile
Justice Center. KRIS TV, October 12, 2007
"I think it's outrageous. It just confirms what many of us suspected –
that there was too close a relationship between the TYC employees and
GEO employees."
Texas State Sen. John Whitmire on learning that the State had hired
former GEO employees to monitor at GEO's troubled Coke County Juvenile
Justice Center. Dallas Morning News, October 12, 2007
"They know how the NRC and licensee operate and feel no one wants to
really find out if anyone is sleeping, because they already know they
are."
Wackenhut (Group 4) whistleblower at the Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station
on NRC ignoring allegations into sleeping guards. York Dispatch,
October 5, 2007
"What were they doing? That's what we're asking. I do imagine that we
will be seeing personnel actions taken as a result of this."
Texas Youth Commission spokesman Jim Hurley on the lack of oversight
by his monitors at the GEO Coke County Juvenile Justice Center.
Dallas Morning News, October 3, 2007
“Times have changed and we simply need to get in front on this issue.”
Idaho Department of Correction Director Brent Reinke after an inmate
suicide at Dickens revealed filthy living conditions and poorly trained
and unprofessional staff at the GEO prison in Texas. Idaho Statesman,
July 31, 2007
"On contracts in general, we're going to be stepping that up. We want to
take a firsthand look."
Idaho Department of Correction Director Brent Reinke on lack of oversight by
the state into GEO prisons in Texas. The Olympian,
July 26, 2007
“Apparently this company is not on top of things, and the state employees
[who ] are over this are not on top of things. No one is checking on
anybody, and this is what happened. It’s just terrible.”
Arkansas Senator Terry Smith on learning about Cornell's losing its
contract at the Alexander Youth Services Center. Arkansas
Democrat-Gazette, November 4, 2006
“Of course it's a problem if the private company is supposed to be
monitoring itself."
I.C.E. overseer John "Kip" Crowther on CCA's monitoring of itself.
CBS5, November 2, 2006
'I'm surprised because of
the way the last contract was handled and terminated and because they
were not the lowest bidder. My concern has always been making sure that
the state fulfilled its end of the contract by imposing the fines."
Florida Senator Dave Aronberg upon learning that the DOC had given a
contract back to Prison Health Services including an extra $250 million
after they pulled out because they weren't making enough money on the
first contract.
Tallahassee Democrat, October 24, 2006
"I am convinced that the
necessary leadership will never be in place until CMS is ousted."
Dr. Jerry Walden in a report to US
District Court in Michigan on the state of health care under
Correctional Medical Services. Detroit Free Press, August 21,
2006
"They didn't have any knowledge of that at all. He was speechless
at that point"
Hernando County Florida Sheriff Richard Nugent about CCA's
management not knowing about CCA's release of an inmate. St.
Petersburg Times,
January 30, 2006
"The corrections department pays the CCA to house inmates and
how they break that down is a question for CCA."
New Mexico Corrections Department's Tia Bland over their position in a
lawsuit over religious programming at CCA's New Mexico Women's Correctional
Facility. Cibola Beacon, November 22, 2005
"The
Private Prison Monitor Unit visits two if not three times a month to check on
the inmates and those inmates are allowed a grievance process"
Colorado DOC spokeswoman Alison Morgan about CCA's Tallahatchie, Mississippi
facility. Pueblo Chieftain,
June 3, 2005
"In
the past we may not have scrutinized it as closely as we maybe ought to
have"
Kentucky Rep. Jesse Crenshaw chairman of the House corrections budget
subcommittee on the state's not fining CCA for contract violations. Courier-Journal,
October 30, 2004
"With private contracts, the key is oversight and monitoring. You
have to hold their feet to the fire."
Doug Sapp, former Kentucky corrections commissioner
after learning CCA prison had no inspectors prior to a recent riot. Courier
Journal, September 29, 2004
"The people in Kentucky were not always
responsive to the complaints raised by our inmates before the riot"
Vermont Corrections Commissioner Steven Gold told legislators after a riot
at CCA's Lee Adjustment Center. Times Argus, September 25, 2004
“I know for a fact that when they know we’re coming things
are really perfect.”
Dr. Laura Bedard, Florida Correctional Privatization Commissioner (CPC), on
dropping in on private prisons unannounced. CPC meeting, March 11, 2004
POLITICAL INFLUENCE
"And how do they get more customers? Enhancing penalties, and
jailing more people."
West Virginia state Supreme Court administrator Steve Canterbury addressing a
House-Senate subcommittee on for-profit private prisons. AP, September
14, 2011
"The only political part of this has been the part where CCA is a very
politically active organization, and so I think the governor is bringing it
in--instead of removing it."
State Rep. Anne Haskell says Maine's corrections department has been remarkably
unpolitical -- until the hiring of a former CCA warden to run the state system.
The new secretary refuses to divest from his CCA stock.
Maine Public
Broadcasting Network, January 25, 2011
"The private-prison industry lobbied heavily against that bill, and they
were successful."
Michael Haener, Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano's lobbyist at the time CCA
killed a bill that would have put oversight on the industry. Arizona Republic,
August 22, 2010
"Kendrick Meek was part of the team that enabled Wackenhut to bilk
Miami-Dade taxpayers out of millions of dollars."
Democratic Senate candidate Maurice Ferre on the influence used by Wackenhut in
Miami-Dade County. Rep. Meek, his wife and mother, a former Congresswoman, are
connected to the company. Miami-Herald, February 19, 2010
''I think it's time we asked and that they proffered. I think it's a fair
question and we'll be taking a look at it.''
Joe Rasco, director of the county (Miami-Dade) Office of Intergovernmental
Affairs when asked if it was a conflict of interest for
former-Congresswoman Carrie Meek to represent both the County and Wackenhut
while the County was overcharged by Wackenhut and Wackenhut is suing the County.
Miami-Herald, May 17, 2009
"Geo should be ashamed and anyone who's rallying behind Geo should also
hold their head in shame."
Texas Youth Commission Acting Executive Director Dimitria Pope on damage
control efforts by GEO supporters after horrid conditions at GEO's Coke County
Juvenile Justice Center came to light. San Antonio Express-News,
October
5, 2007
"Now enters GEO with their
paid lobbyists attempting to put a good face on this," Mr. Whitmire said. "I'm
saying the corporation should back off. They've run a very poor facility that
probably violates the youths' civil rights. ... Kids were stepping in their own
feces. The sheets were such that a cat or dog wouldn't sleep on them."
Texas State Senator John Whitmire on conditions at GEO's Coke County
Juvenile Justice Center. Dallas Morning News, October 5, 2007
"Nobody in our department
has worked for this company in the last six or seven years. They've also worked
for PHS. They've also worked for about a dozen other companies. They go back and
forth between the companies and state service."
Alabama Department of Corrections Commissioner Richard Allen defending his
homeboys before legislative questioning about a CMS contract award. I don't
think realized what he said. Huntsville Times, September 6, 2007
"You give money strategically."
University of Kentucky political scientist
Donald Gross on corporations, like CCA, giving to the governor's mansion
restoration fund. Lexington Herald-Leader, October 25, 2005
"When these out of state interests pour
money into Wisconsin elections, they don't care about our state's well-being.
They are out to obtain benefits for themselves. It's time that Wisconsin
elections were cleaned up and stopping out of state contributions is one way to
start doing that."
Wisconsin Rep. Spencer Black on legislation to ban out-of-state political
contributions. WisPolitics.Com,
October 17,
2005
"With CCA, you have to
look especially because of its political ties. Privatization is payback, it's
political patronage, let's face it, and that troubles me."
Kentucky Rep. Robin Webb on deal with CCA to house 400 female inmates.
Herald-Leader, July 12, 2005
"We see it as the civic responsibility
of a major corporation."
Louise Chickering on CCA's $50,000 donation to Tennessee Governor Mansion face
lift. Tennessean, July
4, 2005
"We
absolutely get no favors in return, and we expect no favors in return."
Louise Chickering on CCA's $100,000 gift to troubled US House Majority Leader
Tom DeLay's legal
defense fund.
Star
Telegram, December 1, 2004
"These political foundations have become
methods for well-heeled corporate executives, lobbyists and others to purchase
influence and face time with top politicians, and without the limits or
disclosure required of campaign donations or lobbying."
Rick Cohen, executive director of the National Committee for Responsive
Philanthropy, on CCA's $100,000 gift to US
House Majority Leader Tom DeLay's legal
defense fund. Star
Telegram, December 1, 2004
''We
are supportive, regardless of party lines, of those individuals that believe in
the private sector playing a role in delivering government services"
CCA spokeswoman Louise Chickering on why its political action
committee has given 96 percent of its money to Republicans so far this election
cycle. AP, October 25, 2004
"We support organizations that want to further
public-private partnerships and efficient government use of taxpayer money."
CCA spokeswoman Louise Chickering on contributing over $370,000 to political
groups in Tennessee. Chattanooga Times Free Press, October 13, 2004
"One thing I underestimated is the politics in this business"
GRW executive Gil Walker on political influence. Tennessean, June 4,
2004
"This is nothing but greed and politics winning over what's best for
the taxpayers."
Florida Correctional Privatization Commissioner Sam Block on the vendors
getting the CPC abolished because they were looking to re-bid their contracts. Tallahassee
Democrat, May 26, 2004
PROFITS
"We'd like to follow up
and perhaps do a performance group review on the private prison operators to see
whether they are making excessive profits."
New Mexicao Rep. Luciano "Lucky" Varela justifying the state not fining CCA and
GEO for staffing vacancies.
New Mexican, April 25, 2011
"To sum it up, you don't want anyone you know to get treatment in their
care. . . . For every dollar of treatment, it's $1 less of profit. So the
incentive is not to provide treatment."
Howard Finkelstein, Broward County (FL) public defender on the difference
between Armor and PHS. Miami Herald, August 19, 2010
"To make a profit the only place you can cut corners is on staffing."
Clive Fairweather, who has previously inspected the private prison at
Kilmarnock, Scotland on a riot at Kalyx's (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. BBC,
January 26, 2010
“The fewer services they provide, the more money they make.”
Seth Lipschutz, supervising attorney at the Vermont Defenders office after
Ashley Ellis died less than two days after entering a Vermont prison from
the careless and negligent operation of a privatized for-profit (PHS)
prison healthcare system. In These Times, December 8, 2009
"Apparently their profitability is somewhat related on what they spend."
Robert Kern, whose 41-year-old son, Daniel, died earlier this month while
serving a one-year sentence for drunken driving. Delaware Medical Examiner's
Office told him his son died of pancreatitis inflammation or infection of the
pancreas. The News Journal, September 30, 2009
"They would go to Frank's door, look in on Frank, [ask] 'Frank, you all
right?' As long as he was living and breathing in that cell, they kept moving."
Patrick Perry, former CCA Captain on why inmate Frank Horton was left in
solitary confinement for over nine months because prison officials refused to
forcibly remove him. Perry claimed it was because they feared too many incidents
involving force could jeopardize staff's yearly bonuses.
NewsChannel 5, October 30, 2008
"This is a for-profit prison. The bottom line is shareholder profit, not
limited recidivism and eliminating assault. The issue is keeping contracts."
Review Panel on Prison Rape Chairman Steven McFarland on why CCA's Torrance
County Detention Center (NM) has a 13.4 percent rate of sexual victimization at
the prison compared with the national average of 3.2 percent. Mountain View
Telegraph, October 9, 2008
"I don't like doing business when we're being held hostage, and that's
exactly what this is."
Colorado Representative Buffie McFayden on
on CCA's demands for a 5 percent increase in payments from the state.
Pueblo Chieftain, February 6, 2008
"They're there to make a profit and they'll cut corners, and they'll cut back
on services and they'll many times look the other way when abuse is taking
place."
Texas State Sen. Juan "Chuy" Hinojosa on privatized prisons at a legislative
hearing on GEO's troubled Coke County Justice Center. KRIS TV, October
12, 2007
"We dismissed the vendor for a failure to produce a profit."
Seal Beach , California police Chief Jeffrey Kirkpatrick, explaining that
the Cornell jail in the city's police station on Seal Beach Boulevard was losing
money. Orange County Register, June 28, 2007
'I'm surprised because of the
way the last contract was handled and terminated and because they were not the
lowest bidder. My concern has always been making sure that the state fulfilled
its end of the contract by imposing the fines."
Florida Senator Dave Aronberg upon learning that the DOC had given a
contract back to Prison Health Services including an extra $250 million after
they pulled out because they weren't making enough money on the first contract.
Tallahassee Democrat, October 24, 2006
"You're dealing with a private business here, and they are in it to
make money and answer to shareholders. Our mission is public safety, and the
ideologies don't always line up"
Oklahoma Corrections Director Justin Jones on Cornell's plan to evict state
inmates for higher paying federal inmates. The Oklahoman, October 12,
2006
"Any plan to artificially reduce
the county jail population will invoke CiviGenics rights to exercise a 30-day
termination provision."
CiviGenics' Chief Operating Officer
Peter Argeropulos on forcing Columbiana County to keep the jail filled.
Salem News, August 12, 2006
``They are all fine people, but their goal is to make money and that is
very different from the public sector goal''
Oklahoma Senator Cal Hobson on legislation allowing for-profits to house
maximum security inmates. KOTV
April 8, 2006
"If
we really do catch more aliens and if we really do lock them up, then we really
do have an important source of growth for the private prison industry."
Andrew May, an analyst with Jefferies and Co. on need for more prison beds
due to the fight against terrorism. Reuters, December 17, 2004
"After
25 years of marketing bigger bombs to kill more people, it got to me"
MTC Chariman Robert Marquardt on getting out of Morton Thiokol and into the
private prison industry. Salt Lake Tribune, August 22, 2004
"Indeed, because a private prison corporation’s first loyalty is to its stockholders, rather than the public interest, it is no surprise that cost-cutting measures jeopardizing prisoners’ rights are more likely in private facilities than in public ones."
US Supreme Court Justice Stevens writing in dissent in Correctional
Services Corporation vs. Malesko,
534 US 61 2001
PROGRAMS
"I thought I was going to a place interested in rehabilitating children.
They were not."
George Cole, former principal at the Walnut Grove Youth Correctional Facility
(GEO Group), told a Mississippi House committee that he also saw evidence of
physical abuse of inmates. AP, January 12, 2011
“There is nothing worse than boredom with a detainee who really doesn’t
know what his future is going to be. This can cause stress, and stress can lead
to trouble and disturbances.”
Independent Monitoring Board chairman Lieutenant Colonel Freddie Cantrell
on GEO's lack of programs at its Campsfield Detention Center (UK) which has a
history of escape attempts and violent incidents. Oxford Mail,
May 18,
2009
"They failed to provide the services they
promised in the contract"
Danny Thompson, director of auxiliary services for the North Carolina
Division of Prisons on taking control of two prison back from CCA. Courier-Journal,
October 30, 2004
"You've got to address those before a guy can get a job, and a lot of
this stuff is busy work. How many people get out there and get a job tying horse
hair?"
Shelby Montana Mayor Larry Bonderud on CCA's inmate programs, Missoula News,
May 20, 2004
PRISON OVERCROWDING
"I would have never thought about prisoners as an import product, but
evidently a Tennessee company and a Tennessee community has found a niche that
works."
David Bohan, chief executive of BOHAN Advertising/Marketing on CCA's promo
video encouraging California inmates to ship out to Tennessee due to
overcrowding. Tennessean, March 6, 2007
"God bless the sheriff. God bless the judges. They are
bringing them in."
Cathy Sullivan, CCA's Hernando County Jail PIO, on jail overcrowding, St.
Petersburg Times, May 18, 2004
PUSHING LEGISLATION
"This is nothing but greed and politics winning out over what's best for the
taxpayers. DMS hasn't got a clue about operating prisons, but the vendors wanted the commission's demise just as soon as we said we were going to rebid the contracts."
Florida Correctional Privatization Commissioner Joel Block on vendors
getting his commission abolished because of threats of contract rebidding, Tallahassee
Democrat, May 26, 2004
"This is the time of year when the
various legislatures are in session. We invest significant time introducing
privatisation legislation and testifying for its adoption. This can be a
lengthy, involved process, but it is vital to our business to have empowering
statutes adopted. Once the statutes are implemented, a request for proposal
usually follows. This legislative process also affords us an opportunity to work
closely with elected officials and thereby understand what is important to them."
Charles R. Jones, Senior VP, Wackenhut,
1996 Annul Report as reported in Prison Privatisation Report International, No.
11 June 1997
RUNNING HOTELS
"The fact that CCA had the right to fill up any extra space with inmates
from other jurisdictions coupled with the governmental entities' paying based on
the number of inmates housed, makes these agreements look more like those
between 'hotels, motels, rooming houses, and other facilities' and 'lodgers or
occupants' than leases for real property."
New Mexico Appeals Court Judge Michael Bustamante on ruling against
CCA's request for a $2.5 million tax rebate. CNN Money, September 19,
2007
"It's not like running a hotel. I'm sorry. Your hotel guests rarely
riot."
Former CCA general counsel Richard Crane on the abrupt resignation of CCA's
Chief Operating Officer, James Seaton a former Marriott hotel executive. Tennessean,
August 11, 2004.
"As long as the industry continues to improve, which we think it will,
these companies will be thought of a hotel companies," he added.
"Because that's really what they do."
Don Hodges, president of Hodges Capital Management, on CCA and GEO, CNN/Money, April 22, 2004
RURAL COMMUNITIES
"With the detention center, nothing has happened easy.
It's been a struggle for us all along, so, in some ways, we were not that
surprised that we've got a continued struggle."
Littlefield, TX, City Manager Danny Davis on news that the bid for his empty
prison formerly run by GEO fell through. KCBD, September 16, 2011
"All of these prisons are in small, rural communities. It's going to
have a tremendous economic impact."
CCA Warden Ralph Kemp on news that Georgia was considering closing one of
three private prisons in the state. Macon Telegraph, October 3, 2004
"I'm used to small towns. Most of CCA's facilities are in small towns,
anywhere from 800 to 1500 people."
CCA Shelby, Montana's Crossroad CC assistant warden Sam Law. Golden
Triangle News, September 8, 2004
SAFETY
“Like clockwork, or maybe as if by pact, all the nurses agreed on the same
approach: They did nothing."
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit in a $1.2 million settlement
given to a Fort Myers man after he was partially paralyzed because of inadequate
care by Corizon (PHS) during a stint in the Lee County (FL) Jail. News-Press,
September 9, 2012
"I was literally shaking with fear. There was a note saying they were going
to tie me up, rape me, then kill me and I wasn't even made aware. They played
Russian roulette with my life."
Rose Forsyth, 32, alleges a note was discovered with detailed plans of how the
group of up to nine inmates - most convicted of serious sexual offences - were
going to carry out the horrifying abuse and then chillingly kill her and was not
told of the plan by GEO. Sunday Herald Sun, May 20, 2012
"To have a prison that's chaotic, poorly run, dangerous, didn't provide
services, highly sexualized and highly violent really limits the ability of the
state to turn those folks around, and to ensure public safety upon their release
from prison."
Jonathan Smith, chief of special litigation in the civil rights section at the
Justice Department, about GEO's Walnut Grove Detention Center. NPR, April
24, 2012
"It means something is wrong."
Burnet County (TX) Judge Donna Klaeger on the dire conditions of the LaSalle
Southwestern jail where an inmate escaped by removing a rail by a toilet and
chiseled away at cinder blocks under a sink until he created an escape route.
Daily Tribune, March 5, 2012
“We were falling behind on our time period for doing our TB tests.”
Richard Harbison, LCS’ executive vice president, on the problem with
tuberculosis in their East Hidalgo Detention Center. The Monitor, March
3, 2012
''I was told the scenario was unrealistic and would never happen."
Assistant Police Commissioner, Frank Mennilli, told politicians, at hearing on
riots by detainees that cost millions of dollars in damages, that Villawood
(Australia) was not secure. Sydney Morning Herald, October 6, 2011
"There are likely to be significant risk to health and safety associated with
the relocation of the Christmas Island detainees to the Villawood IDF."
A safety order issues by Comcare less than three weeks before a riot at the
Serco Villawood (Ausralia) prison.
The Daily Telegraph, June 3, 2011
“There were alarms that never worked. There were doors propped open with
rocks.”
Mohave County (Arizona) Sheriff Tom Sheahan on MTC's lax security at its Kingman
prison. The Daily News,
May 8, 2011
"These contractors threaten the security of our troops and risk the success
of our mission."
Sen. Carl Levin, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee on their report
on private security in Afghanistan showing companies hiring guards with Taliban
connections, NBC News, October 8, 2010
"What was found were excessive false alarms. The system was not maintained or
calibrated."
Arizona Corrections Director Charles Ryan on MTC recording 89 false alarms in
one 16 hour period before the escape of three violent criminals from the Arizona
State Prison in Kingman. Arizona Star, August 20, 2010
"He's a twisted guy. Why weren't they in a maximum-security facility?"
Bryan Knoblich, whose father was murdered years ago by one of three escapees
from MTC's Arizona State Prison. The facility is built to hold DUI prisoners.
Arizona Republic, August 3, 2010
"Our surveys, interviews and observations all evidenced a degree of
despair amongst detainees about safety at Brook House which we have rarely
encountered. At the time of the inspection, Brook House was an unsafe place."
Chief Inspector of Prisons (UK) Dame Anne Owers on report about Group 4 run
Brook House detention prison.
The Guardian, July 12, 2010
"There were an obvious number of indicators that should have set off
bells and whistles."
Delaware County (PA) District Attorney G. Michael Green on the accidental
release of an inmate at CEC's George W. Hill Correctional Facility.
Philadelphia Daily News, June 16, 2010
"Is this prison unsafe, and are there some major security breaches?"
State Sen. Will Espero (HI), chairman of the Senate Public Safety Committee,
about two inmate deaths at CCA's Saguaro Prison in Arizona. Star-Advertiser,
June 15, 2010
"Unfortunately, private prisons are run to make a profit. Ultimately, the
company in charge of them has to deliver for their shareholders and so they have
to find ways to make money. The way to do this is by having fewer staff, paying
low wages, investing less money in training and pensions, and this impacts on
the running of the prison. For a prison to run properly, you need the guards and
the prisoners to understand each other and work with each other, and that
requires experienced guards. That takes an investment in training and keeping
staff, which can be at odds with the need to deliver a profit."
Former Chief Inspector of Prisons (Scotland) Sir Clive Fairweather on the cause
of a riot at the Kalyx (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. Edinburgh Evening News,
January 28, 2010
"We are all aware that we work in a prison, but allowing one prisoner to
perpetrate four assaults in six months and still stay medium security needs to
be addressed."
Serco employee about the Acacia prison in Australia. The Western Australian,
December 31, 2009
“It’s a real problem. On average there’s one mobile for every 10
prisoners."
UK Prison Officers Association spokesman Glynn Travis on the rampant cell
phone problem at Group 4's Altcourse Prison. Liverpool Echo, November 5,
2009
"There are inherent safety issues. We don't allow private prison
contractors to run high-custody beds, and the entire complex is a secured area."
Colorado Rep. Buffie McFadyen on a proposal to sell a brand new high security
public prison to a private vendor. Pueblo Chieftain, October 25, 2009
“Medical care in this facility does not meet ICE standards."
John P. Torres, director of detention and removal operations, after looking into
the suicide of a 32-year-old Guatemalan detainee at CCA's Eloy Detention Center
(AZ). New York Times, August 21, 2009
"If there's a desire to bring prisoners home -- whether they're male or
female prisoners -- we're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars that we
don't have right now."
Hawai'i Governor Linda Lingle placing cost over the safety of her female inmates
allegedly being raped at CCA Otter Creek prison in Kentucky. Star-Bulletin,
July 12, 2009
"In this post-9/11 world that we're now living in, I cannot fathom how
security breaches of this magnitude were allowed to occur."
US Sen. Susan Collins on a report by the Government Accountability Office on the
lack of security at Federal buildings by private security guards. Government
Executive, July 8, 2009
“We have been in the middle of a Mexican drug cartel war which has spilled
into the prison. We all fear for our safety and if or when one of us does get
hurt, no one can say that we did not warn them.”
Canadian Brent James Curtis about CCA's California City Correctional Center. The
prison was locked down 47 days over a three month period. Ottawa
Citizen, July 2, 2009
“It is an absolute tragedy that a prisoner in the care of the state could
end up dying in that condition.”
West Australian Premier Colin Barnett on the death of a tribal elder in the back
of a Group 4 van. The West,
June 23, 2009
"Undoubtedly, a private company would pay its employees significantly
lower wages and provide them lesser training to realize cost savings. This would
lead to higher staff turnover, low morale and place public safety at risk."
Arizona DOC Director Charles Ryan in a letter to Gov. Jan Brewer on a plan to
sell its public prisons to for-profit corporations. Arizona Republic,
June 14, 2009
"My back didn't get any kind of attention at all, other than ibuprofen. I
was told by the director of medical to shut up ... They said no to everything."
Convicted former Rep. Vic Kohring (AK) on his stay at the Taft
Correctional Institution (CA) run by MTC.
Anchorage Daily-News, June 13,
2009
“This is a damning indictment of the present criminal justice system
which is chronically overcrowded."
South Wales Central AM Leanne Wood, after a report on extremely high levels of
inmate on inmate violence at Group 4's Parc Prison (UK). South Wales Echo,
June 8, 2009
“The physical plant in Perry, frankly, was not very conducive to the type
of inmates they sent us.”
Richard Harbison, executive vice president of LCS Corrections Services, on
Vermont pulling its inmates from the Perry County Detention Facility (AL) after
many assaults on their inmates. Seven Days, May 27, 2009
“Of course it shouldn’t happen. It means there is a weakness in the
security. Of course that has been rectified.”
Independent Monitoring Board chairman Lieutenant Colonel Freddie Cantrell on
the escape of seven detainees from GEO's Campsfield Detention Center (UK) which
has a history of escape attempts and violent incidents. Oxford Mail, May
18, 2009
"Operating [a closed-monitoring] institution with reduced and
inexperienced staffing in an effort to save money is not an option. To do so
puts public safety at risk."
Florida DOC Secretary Walt McNeil in letter to Florida Senate President Jeff
Atwater regarding a proposal to privatize a public close security prison.
Orlando-Sentinel, May 9, 2009
"If (the warder) is the only one with a key, then every time a prisoner
wants to go in and out of their cell you've got to send somebody to look at it."
Gary Sturgess, research director of the Serco Group and former cabinet chief,
told the New South Wales parliamentary why Serco wants to give keys to inmates.
The Australian, March 27, 2009
"Cell phones in the hands of inmates, that's a major breach of security."
Kevin Dean, Florida Correction Department's canine supervisor on the high
number of cell phones found at GEO Group's South Bay Facility. Sun-Sentinel,
February 8, 2009
"They took over the compound," he said. "They burned half the stuff over
there."
GEO guard Matt Guerra as over 2,000 inmates riot at the Reeves County (TX)
Detention Center. AP, February 1, 2009
"Inattentiveness on the part of those charged with the vital task of
protecting and operating our nuclear power plants [is] completely unacceptable."
Nuclear Regulatory Commission on Wackenhut (Group 4) guards sleeping on the job.
Chicago Tribune,
January 6, 2009
"Things just plain aren't getting done."
Patti Barber, Mississippi CURE, about the chronic health needs of inmates not
being met by Wexford as outlined by the Legislature's Joint Committee on
Performance Evaluation and Expenditure Review found in a report on inmate health
care. Clarion Ledger, November 23, 2008
"When you're in that profit driven business and your overhead begins to
grow and your profit margin begins to shrink, you begin to take short cuts and
people get hurt."
Johnson County, Missouri Sheriff Charles Heiss about the escape of two very
dangerous from the Integrity Correctional Center. FOX 4 News,
September 29, 2008
"No one knows it until they lived it."
Former CCA nurse Kathy Baucum after being fired by CCA for refusing to put
herself into a dangerous situation that reminder her of a hostage situation she
survived at the Bay County Jail 4 years earlier. New-Herald, September 18, 2008
"I don't know how these inmates were able to get to the control panel and
unlock all of the jail cells."
Attorney Lawrence Stacey on threats and beating his clients took at
CiviGenics' Columbiana County Jail (OH). Morning Journal News, August 29,
2008
"Obviously this is something we're concerned about. We'll get to the
bottom of it."
CiviGenics Senior Vice President Peter Argeropulos about the escape of four
inmates from their Columbiana County Jail in Ohio. Salem News,
August 19, 2008
"Bathing, yes. Bathing's a big deal. Poor hygiene is a big problem."
University of South Florida pathogenic microbiologist Lindsey Shaw on claims
that CCA water was turned off for days at a time at their Gadsden prison for
women, apparently as a cost-cutting measure leading to the death of an inmate
due to MRSA. Fort Mills Times, August 13, 2008
"The Monitoring Team has found that the lack of stable and effective
leadership at the vendor-level remains a concern."
Independent monitor regarding Correctional Medical Service's problems at the
Delaware Department of Corrections. News Journal, July 30, 2008
"In a correctional facility, anytime you open a door there's a chance
there's something not authorized coming through."
GEO's Lawton Correctional Facility (Oklahoma) warden David Miller on the problem
with cell phones in their facility. KSWO, July 29, 2008
"Unsafe and unstable."
Inquest into the stabbing death of Global Solutions inmate in their Rye Hill
Prison. BBC, July 16, 2008
"We conclude that our above findings in relation to Rye Hill prison
created an environment that contributed to the death of Wayne Reid."
Inquest into the stabbing death of Global Solutions inmate in their Rye Hill
Prison. BBC, June 26, 2008
"That concerns me a lot."
Gallatin County (MT) Sheriff Jim Cashell on a CiviGenics spec prison proposal
that relies on a non-existing law enforcement authority to help in the event of
an incident at their prison. Billings Gazette, June 17, 2008
"The prison had deteriorated to the extent that we considered that it was
at that time an unsafe and unstable environment both for prisoners and staff."
Tom Osbourne, assistant deputy coroner for Northamptonshire (UK), on an
inspection made days before an inmate was stabbed to death at Global Solutions
(now Group 4) run Rye Hill. BBC, June 16, 2008
"It's messed up."
CCA guard at the Crowley Correctional Facility about why the computer screen
showed the cell doors open when in fact they were closed to reporter Maria
Hinojosa. NOW, May 9, 2008
"I think you saw us [in] April at our worst."
Ernie Dixon, director of operations for The GEO Group, about the costs
a riot in 2007 at GEO's New Castle Correctional Facility is causing. The Star
Press, April 24, 2008
"It's indefensible, in my opinion, that we put kids in a facility that's
inadequate for adults."
Natrona Country, Wyoming Commissioner Matt Keating on a report that their
troubled juvenile facility had been deemed unsuitable for adults years before.
AP, April 19, 2008
"The inmate wasn't five minutes down the road by the time I hit the doors
to report it."
Woman told KENS 5 that she tried to warn GEO guards that Esequiel Pena had
broken out, but she says they didn’t listen. KENS 5 News, April 1,
2008
"It's a tragic lapse of judgment."
John Reilly, GEO's George W Hill prison's acting superintendent on one of their
guards being charged with having sex with a trustee. Philadelphia Daily News,
March 26, 2008
“It might be more realistic to empty the centre briefly, so that
it can be relaunched with a properly trained and reinvigorated staff, focused on
plenty of good-quality, purposeful activity, dynamic security, and an emphasis
on appropriate behaviour within clear boundaries.”
Anne Owers, UK Chief Inspector of Prisons, suggestion to close the jail after
finding a lack of control and order at Group 4's Oakhill Secure Training Unit. The Times, March 17, 2008
"We need a formal way for him to be picked back up. And I would hate to
hear that when this thing settles down, we look back and he was pulled over in
Arkansas but there was no warrant, and therefore he was released.”
Davidson County Tennessee Sheriff Daron Hall on why it took CCA two
days before getting a warrant issues for an escapee from their Metro Davidson
County Detention Center. WSMV, February 20, 2008
"It is a matter of public safety. (Other states) are exporting their
worst criminals to Arizona, and we can't even know what they are doing and what
steps they are taking to protect Arizonans."
Dennis Burke, Arizona Governor Napolitano's chief of staff on legislation
to open private prisons in Arizona to public scrutiny. Arizona Republic,
February 1, 2008
"What I emphasized to them is what occurred is a security breach. Once I
got word of the suicide and how it occurred, my initial reaction was, how did a
gun get in there?"
Clayton Frank, director of the Hawai'i Department of Public Safety, after a CCA
employee committed suicide at the Otter Creek Correctional Facility. Honolulu
Advertiser, January 26, 2008
"As a result of two or three things and my on-going concern about the jail, about staffing
and (personnel) training and other issues, we asked the county
commission to start looking into it prior to the uprising, which
highlighted the need for commissioners to review their contract with
Cornell Companies. I felt our office had to intervene."
New Mexico 12th Judicial District Attorney Scot Key on a Grand Jury
investigation into Cornell operations at the Lincoln County Detention
Center. Ruidoso News, January 25, 2008
"Custody officers claimed that staffing levels could at times be
dangerously low, especially in ‘A’ wing and at weekends. They said that two
members of staff had been assaulted over the past year, while there had also
been a large number of less serious incidents. We sensed generally that staff
seemed to be even more concerned about safety than they had been a year ago (and
being under complement could also have contributed to this). Examples were cited
where it was impossible to arrange relief cover for toilet breaks, meaning that
prisoners were left unsupervised, except by CCTV, during these periods."
Scotland Chief Prison Inspector Clive Fairweather on a recent report
on Premier's Kilmarnock Prison. Scotland on
Sunday, January 6, 2008
"It is of concern that witnesses spoke of a culture that involves staff
favouritism; the centre being dominated by a few staff; tolerance of abuse of
prisoners; and an environment where speaking out means job loss."
Victorian Ombudsman George Brouwer on a beating of a detainee at GEO's
Melbourne Custody Center. The Age, November 22, 2007
“That kind of carelessness is something we can’t have. I mean,
they’re running a jail.”
Bay County, Florida Commissioner Mike Nelson on recent accidental
release of four inmates from CCA's Bay County Jail. News Herald, November
14, 2007
"To me, it looked like one employee didn't do their job.”
Eldon McCumber, the Hinton (Oklahoma) Economic Development Authority's
chairman brushing off reports that Cornell's Great Plains Correctional Facility
had major security issues after two murderers escaped. The Oklahoman,
October 9, 2007
"When we saw what a terrible job they were doing at Coke County, TYC had
the ability to shut it down and move their youth."
Texas Sen. John Whitmire, chairman of the Senate Criminal Justice Committee,
cited the "terrible job" Geo Group Inc. did running the West Texas youth lockup
and said he plans to review adult corrections contracts the state has with the
company. Houston Chronicle, October 5, 2007
"We have serious doubts about their (Cornell's) ability to provide the
safe and humane environment we want for our detainees. That's the reason we are
not there."
Gary Mead, assistant director for detention and removal operations for ICE,
on why ICE removed their detainees from Cornell's Regional Correctional Center
in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Albuquerque Tribune, September 13,
2007
"It's a half-mile from the high school, so the type of prisoner they're
bringing in there concerns me."
Epps, Louisiana Mayor Jeff Guice on Emerald Correction's lack of
openness on its West Carroll Detention Center. Houston Chronicle,
July 22, 2007
"Considering the millions of dollars that we are spending on the
Mainland, we would expect to get excellent service, excellent facilities, and
... I would expect that with their experience, they should be able to minimize
any problems,"
Hawai'i Senate Public Safety Committee Chairman Will Espero upon learning
that CCA had another mistaken cell door opening leading to inmate beating.
Honolulu Advertiser, July 18, 2007
"Something's not right, and we need to make sure that we have an
understanding of what this problem is."
Virginia state Sen. Kenneth W. Stolle about problems with contraband at
GEO's Lawrenceville Correctional Center. Times Dispatch, May 23, 2007
"We believe we have reasonable grounds to believe the camp presents a
substantial danger to public health, safety and welfare"
Liz McDonough, a spokeswoman for the Colorado Department of Health and Human
Services on closing CEC's
Alternative Youth Adventure after a 15 year-old died of a staph infection.
Denver Post, May 11, 2007
"They have been understaffed"
GEO guard's wife, Twilla Deaton on staffing issues after a riot at GEO's New
Castle CF. The Star Press, April 25, 2007
"There were serious security concerns"
Arizona Department of Corrections spokeswoman Katie Decker on concerns over
GEO's staffing levels at their New Castle CF in Indiana after a riot by over 500
inmates. The Indianapolis Star,
April 25, 2007
"Straight from the start I had expressed concern about the level of
support and training. I told senior management about it and they didn't do
anything."
Global Solutions Ltd Guard Daniel Daymond after a scathing report on an
inmate's suicide. The Guardian, April 3, 2007
"CCA is in the position that we don't make excuses for an escape because
there is none"
CCA's Hernando County Jail Warden Russell Washburn on why it took CCA four
hours to inform the local sheriff that an inmate had escaped from his jail.
St Petersburg Times, February 28, 2007
"You're dealing with a private business here, and they are in it
to make money and answer to shareholders. Our mission is public safety, and the
ideologies don't always line up"
Oklahoma Corrections Director Justin Jones on Cornell's plan to evict state
inmates for higher paying federal inmates. The Oklahoman, October 12,
2006
"Basically, anybody could have gotten to them."
LCS co-owner Richard Harbison about how easy it was to tamper with a
electrical fence control box (located in the ground, out in the open) at their
East Hidalgo Detention Center, TX where six inmates escaped. KRIS TV,
September 23, 2006
''The way we see it, there
is lack of security there right now. There are a lot of safety issues pertaining
to that"
Joe Magallan, a deputy with the U.S. Marshals Service
in Texas, on LCS' problems after an escape of six inmates from their East
Hidalgo Detention Center. Houston Chronicle, September 21, 2006
"Prisoners in private prisons are no less violent, they're
no less difficult. You are twice as likely to be attacked in a private prison as
in a public prison. "
UK Prison Officers Association national general secretary Brian Caton on the use
of batons in prison in the UK. 24
DASH, April 23, 2006
"Anytime
you put an inmate in transport vans you put them in a less secure environment."
CCA's Bay County Jail Warden Kevin Watson on recent escape of CCA inmate
from a TransCor van with faulty locks. News Herald, February 24, 2005
"When incidents of this nature
occur, they cause the courts, law enforcement and the public to question the
operation and security of the jail."
Hernando County
Purchasing Director James Gantt on CCA's escape troubles. Hernando Today,
December 22, 2004
"The way the jail is run, the
way it was run when I was there scares me, it doesn’t feel safe ever."
CCA guard James Hall about the Bay County Jail. News-Herald, December
9, 2004
"There's
no qualitative measure of what's safe."
Peter Mount, communications director at MTC's
Central North Correctional Centre
when asked by if the super jail is a safe place after three stabbings in 2004. Midland
Mirror, October 13, 2004
“They’re
not escaping, they are simply walking away from the facility."
Lisa Tauser, communications director
for Cornell after a recent spat of escapes from their Southern Peaks Treatment
Facility in Colorado. Canon Cafe,
October 8, 2004
"Everything I've worked to do here is going to
go right down the drain because of incidents like this."
MTC jail
Warden Kerry Dixon on an inmate rape at Santa Fe Jail.
Santa Fe New Mexican September 30, 2004
"Are we surprised that
something like this happened and we're involved in it? Yes we are. In the six or
seven years we've been doing business like this out of state it's the first time
this has happened."
Ray
Flum, director of inmate classification for the Vermont Department of
Corrections, on Vermont inmate's riot at CCA's Lee Adjustment Center in
Kentucky. AP, September 17, 2004
"Having six breakouts in the past eight years and only catching one
of the 15 that have escaped, that's pretty scary."
Pearsall Mayor Roland Segovia on CSC's Frio County Jail on recent
escape of five inmates. WOAI News 5,
August 10, 2004
"It's absurd. How could you cut two holes through the fences and just
walk out? Don't they have people watching them?"
Pearsall, TX resident Judy Stacy who lives two blocks from CSC's Frio County
Jail on recent escape of five inmates. Express-News, August 8, 2004
"Why should the
public worry about them fighting on the inside."
Tutwiler, MS. Mayor Robert Grayson on gang-related violence at CCA's
Tallahatchie prison. Clarion Ledger,
May 25, 2004
SALARIES
"Yes, we're going to pay a higher starting salary than CCA pays."
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on paying over $7,000 more
per year to employees after taking over the jail from CCA. Hernando
Today, June 24, 2010
"They're just paying some standard wages for the area. That's cut and
dry. They're breaking down the standard of living for us out here."
Darrell Fagg, representative of Iron Workers Local 433 regarding why CCA
was not paying prevailing wages to workers building a CCA facility in
Pahrump, NV. Pahrump Valley Times, October 21, 2009
"It is not a federal project, there's not federal dollars in the
construction activity, therefore we're not governed by prevailing wage."
Buddy Johns, senior director of project development for CCA regarding
why CCA was not paying prevailing wages to workers building a CCA
facility in Pahrump, NV. Pahrump Valley Times, October 21,
2009
"Undoubtedly, a private company would pay its employees significantly
lower wages and provide them lesser training to realize cost savings.
This would lead to higher staff turnover, low morale and place public
safety at risk."
Arizona DOC Director Charles Ryan in a letter to Gov. Jan Brewer on a
plan to sell its public prisons to for-profit corporations. Arizona
Republic, June 14, 2009
“This employer refuses to give them a pay raise of any sort.”
Union chief negotiator Howard Johannssen about GEO Group guards going on
strike. News 4 WOAI , January 14, 2009
“We do see turnover. But I don't think it’s turnover because of the
facility itself, I think it's turnover because 'I can make more money.'”
Torrance County (NM) Sheriff Clarence Gibson trying to explain away
his CCA's jail highest level of rape then any jail in the US. KOAT,
October 1, 2008
"It's a little higher rate. But let's face it; a lot of the problems have
been because of the salary."
Bay County (Florida) Commission Chairman Jerry Girvin on the Sheriff
taking over the Bay County Jail from CCA. News-Herald, June 3,
2008
"There were not very many jobs out here. Any time you could take a state
job, it was a better job for everybody because it paid more money. That's the
only reason. It was like a step up from GEO. That's the way everybody viewed
it."
Patti Frazee, former Texas state monitor clerk at GEO's troubled Coke County
Juvenile Justice Center on why locals took jobs with the state after working for
GEO. Dallas Morning News, October 12, 2007
"We cash (the guard's) paychecks, and I can tell you they make about $6
an hour — or about what we pay our clerks."
Epps, Louisiana Crystal Hale, 33, who runs the Best Way market on Emerald
Correction's pay at its West Carroll Detention Center. Houston Chronicle,
July 22, 2007
"The guards make $18,000 a year and the inmates are walking around
with a thousand dollars in cash on them"
Former GEO Group inmate David Eugene Davis about his experience at GEO's
Lawrenceville Correctional Facility in Virginia where over half the states
illegal drugs are found. Richmond Times-Dispatch, March 18, 2007
"The
few privatized jails I've seen have a tendency to pay minimum wage or slightly
above, so you're going to have a problem with staff turnover."
American Jails managing editor Ken Kerle on pay and turnover at for-profits.
Beaufort Gazette, November 12, 2005
"It is a challenge in trying to make salaries competitive
with what is paid by the state."
CCA spokesman Steve Owen on competing with Colorado DOC pay and benefits. Rocky
Mountain News,
November 12, 2005
"But it's not necessarily going to be at the
salary and benefits that they have now."
Beaver County, Pennsylvania Controller
Rick Towcimak on CiviGenics taking over their jail. Beaver County Times,
September 8, 2005
"I don't care who you work for, if you pay your people $6,000 more,
you're going to get more people working that you want working for you and fewer
that you don't. That's just a fact."
Florida Juvenile Justice Association lobbyist Mark Fontaine on why public
facilities have less staff turnover than private ones. Palm Beach Post, December
5, 2004
"Originally, we thought people were going to start at $14 or $15 an
hour, and instead they started at $8 or $9."
Brenda Loncake, Shelby, MT realtor about CCA pay, Missoula News, May 20,
2004
SECRECY
"Thus, after four years, CCA is still fighting hard to avoid
producing the records I requested, which would have to be produced if I
requested them from any public agency. This is a perfect example of the lack of
transparency and lack of public accountability in the private prison industry."
Alex Friedmann, Prison Legal News, in their attempt to get CCA to release
records in Tennessee after the courts ruled in Friedmann's favor. Nashville
Scene, January 26, 2012
“When you're dealing with a private entity like that, you're
kind of at their mercy. We keep being told that they're going to present
charges, but they're just taking time to do it.”
Beckham County (OK) District Attorney Dennis Smith said about CCA's
investigation of a riot in October 2011. Oklahoman, January 14, 2012
“At some point, if they want charges filed, they'll have to
turn it over to us.”
Sayre (OK) Police Chief Ronnie Harrold said he has yet to receive anything from
CCA regarding a riot in October. He said he thinks something is close to
happening, but that the prison corporation has “been giving us the runaround.”
Oklahoman, December 10, 2011
“I don’t know anything about it. All I know is what I read in
the paper.”
Ashtabula County (OH) Sheriff William Johnson about not being told his agency
was going to pick up the cost of policing incidents at CCA's new prison taken
over from the public. Star Beacon, October 21, 2011
"This report is quite damning [in] that there is a culture of
non-disclosure, a culture of secrecy, total lack of transparency and what we see
is we don't know how many cases of self-harm there are, how many incidents that
have had to be escalated to different levels."
Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young on a wide-ranging report delivered by Comcare,
the Federal Government's (Australia) workplace safety agency. ABC, August
11, 2011
"If you do nothing, I think there will be a court case. I think people will
expect or assume they'll be able to get records."
Vermont Legislative counsel Michael O'Grady on open access to CCA's records.
Burlington Free Press, July 28, 2011
"We find it very strange that we need to get permission to gain access."
South Africa Corrections Commissioner Tom Moyane on getting access to two
private prisons. Mail & Guardian,
June 23, 2011
“So the list of items that could qualify as a breach of the contract are
not public, and the department doesn’t audit the list of breaches — what
breaches happen, how many breaches happen — at what stage is there any type of
transparency?”
Australian Senator Hanson-Young on not only is the $1 billion contract
awarded to detention centre operator Serco beyond the reach of public scrutiny,
but Senate Estimates hearings today revealed that the Department of Immigration
and Citizenship collects scant data on breaches and has limited knowledge and
oversight of staff training levels. TangataWhenua.com,
May 30, 2011
"We can't got into detail on the total amount of any fines imposed, as
this information is considered commercial-in-confidence."
Australian Department of Immigration and Citizenship spokesperson on why they
could not release information about Serco fines. The Australian, May 12,
2011
"The state can outsource public functions and services such as health
care for prisoners but it cannot contract out the public’s fundamental right to
know how their tax dollars are being spent and the quality of services the
public is getting for its money."
Prison Legal News Editor Paul Wright on suing Prison Health Services for records
related to the death of an inmate under their care in Vermont. Serious News,
August 26, 2010
"The Department was also not advised immediately about the escape by
Management Training Corporation and it's unfortunate it took as long as it did."
Arizona Department of Corrections director Charles Ryan on why it took over 19
hours for the victim of the escape of a murderer from an MTC prison. KGUN9-TV,
August 3, 2010
"We no longer know what kind of background checks have happened or any
kind of those details."
Milwaukee County (WI) 4th District Supervisor Marina Dimitrijevic on Wackenhut
(Group 4) taking over inmate transport services for the county jail. TMJS,
May 28, 2010
"There were a lot of things GEO was hiding that day."
Former corrections officer Michelle Terrien was the center of a bizarre triangle
within the South Bay Correctional Facility (FL) run by the GEO Group. Palm
Beach Post, January 5, 2010
"It's legally inappropriate. ... And I question why an agency would renew
a contract with someone who doesn't comply with the law. Any vendor that doesn't
want to recognize legal authority shouldn't be a government contractor anymore."
Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association,
on Correctional Care's attempt to keep financial records secret. The
Times-Tribune, November 10, 2009
"My job is not to give you the answers you want my job is to give the
information I've been employed to release or not release."
American Police Force spokesperson Becky Shay in response to who and what was
APF. KULR, October 2, 2009
“This is a serious issue that’s going on out there at that facility that
I think we need to try to get our hands on before it goes too far."
Leflore County (MS) Supervisor Wayne Self said during a board meeting Tuesday
that an inmate assaulted a guard at the medium-security Greenwood prison a
couple of weeks ago. Accounts of the altercation leaked out of the facility,.
Greenwood Commonwealth, September 9, 2009
"Too often the public is denied information about the costs of hospital,
school and prison contracts on the grounds of commercial prejudice or commercial
confidentiality" he said. "This decision is extremely important and should help
pave the way for greater access to information about all PFI/PPP contracts."
Unison's Scottish organiser Dave Watson said the union had long argued there was
too much secrecy around public-private financing regarding Serco's £50m
PFI contract for Kilmarnock jail. The Scottish
Information Commissioner ruled this financial information was a public record..
BBC, September 9, 2009
"During this time, the county has continually asked for, inquired about
and pursued payment for the expanded capacity beds. … We have continually been
ignored."
Hernando County (FL) Purchasing Director James Gantt on CCA's reneging on a
shared revenue plan.
St Petersburg Times, July 28, 2009
“If one of the largest unions in the state can’t get the information,
what makes you think an individual like me can.”
Santa Rosa (FL) community activist Alan Isaacson on trying to get records
from a local economic development council. The Florida PBA has been working on
records related to a GEO Group prison built there. Santa Rosa
Press-Gazette, Jul y 24, 2009
"If the process had been more transparent, there probably would have been
other state officials who would've said, 'I don't know if GEO is the best use of
state dollars.' "
Monica Thyssen, children's mental health policy specialist with Advocacy Inc.
(TX) on the GEO Group's getting inserted an earmark into the state budget to
fund the future Montgomery County facility that no legislator wants to own up
to. Dallas Morning News, July 10, 2009
"We've asked and asked and asked for how they account for this."
Hernando County (FL) Purchasing Director James Gantt on CCA's lack of
providing the county information on a
shared revenue plan. Hernando Today, July 7, 2009
"I feel we're not getting enough information from them to satisfy my
needs."
Hernando County (FL) Commissioner Jim Adkins on CCA not giving information
regarding their operations of the county jail. Hernando Today, June 25,
2009
"My concern relates to inmate safety at ICC resulting from the increased
violence in recent months."
Former Virtual Prison Program Warden Randy Blades (ID) about concerns over CCA
not fully investigating cases of inmate-on-inmate violence and weren't reporting
major inmate crimes to the Ada County Sheriff's office for investigation and
prosecution. The Olympian, April 4, 2009
"It's not a crime to escape from a private jail. Once the prison told
Johnson County about the escape, the sheriff's office said there was nothing
they could do because no crime was committed."
Missouri Sen. David Pearce on his bill requiring private prisons and jails to
report escapes after two inmates escaped from a private jail at about 5 a.m. but
the sheriff's office was not notified until 1 p.m. that day, and local residents
were not informed until even later. Columbia Missourian, March 13, 2009
“Access to the information increases the likelihood of escape attempts
and makes power and phone lines vulnerable.”
GEO Group attorney Joan Mell on why they went to court to keep the public from
seeing the records for the Northwest Detention Center in Tacoma, WA.
The News Tribune, March 21, 2009
"It was bad enough when they built it in the first place but to be
fed this rubbish that they weren't going to make it any bigger and then see the
prefabricated cells carted past my front door is just a joke. They have been so
sneaky and underhanded."
John Hitchins about the stealth expansion of Kalyx's Bronzefield prison in
Ashford (UK). Staines News, March 6, 2009
"Taxpayers have a right to know how their money is being spent."
Alex Friedmann, a former inmate who is now an advocate and associate editor for
Prison Legal News, has taken the nation's largest for-profit prison operator to
court, seeking access to public records under the Tennessee Public Records Act.
Tennessean, March 6, 2009
"Let’s ask for it. If we ask for it and get no comment, then that’s
what we get. Let’s send them a letter and ask them for the information.”
Oklahoma Board of Corrections member David Henneke on comments by GEO
warden David Miller that private prisons are private businesses, there is little
obligation for them to give the state information on formulas to set rates.
Oklahoman, February 13, 2009
"One of my goals is to be low-key and below the radar screen. And so far
so good."
CCA's Torrance County (NM) Detention Facility Warden Robert Ezell on avoiding
the public scrutiny regarding his facility having a high rape rate. Mountain
View Telegraph, February 5, 2009
“We can’t do a whole lot of talking right now.”
Greg Hess, vice-chairman of the Storey County Commission (NV) on a Texas private
prison's (Cornell?) plan for a prison in his community. Reno Gazette-Journal,
December 12, 2008
"We welcome legislation that will help protect our citizens."
Johnson County (MO) Sheriff Charles Heiss on proposed legislation requiring
private jails to report incidents at their facilities after Integrity
Correctional Center waited 15 hours to report the escape of two inmates from
their Johnson County facility. Herald-Tribune, October 4, 2008
"WSI feels we have provided sufficient information on this issue and we
don't want to further discuss the phone policy, other than to say that we
reviewed it and revised it following the incident in question."
Wackenhut (Group 4) spokeswoman Courtney Henry when asked to provide details
regarding the security's contractor's previous and current phone policies.
Knoxville News, September 25, 2008
"I was very upset, upset with the jail for not notifying us."
Katherine Clifton about the escape of two very dangerous criminals from
Integrity Correctional Centers jail in Johnson County (MO) and not being
notified for over 12 hours of the escape. FOX 4 News, September
1, 2008
"It is a matter of public safety. (Other states) are exporting their
worst criminals to Arizona, and we can't even know what they are doing and what
steps they are taking to protect Arizonans."
Dennis Burke, Arizona Governor Napolitano's chief of staff on legislation
to open private prisons in Arizona to public scrutiny. Arizona Republic,
February 1, 2008
"This a private settlement among private parties, and I'm obliged not to
disclose the dollar amount."
Honolulu lawyer Myles Breiner on a settlement with GRW and two Hawai'i inmates
who were sexually assaulted at the Brush Correctional Facility in Colorado.
Honolulu Advertiser, January 8, 2008
"The private prison contractor and the Government have a common interest
in burying the issues."
Hugh de Kretser, executive officer of the Federation of Community Legal
Centres on the difficulty in getting access to information a private prisons and
jails in Australia. The Age, November 24, 2007
"It is of concern that witnesses spoke of a culture that involves staff
favouritism; the centre being dominated by a few staff; tolerance of abuse of
prisoners; and an environment where speaking out means job loss."
Victorian Ombudsman George Brouwer on a beating of a detainee at GEO's
Melbourne Custody Center. The Age, November 22, 2007
"What I'm really upset about is there was a seven hour delay before
anyone at our place was ever notified, and what concerns me even more is what
else is going on our there that we don't even know about?"
Mike Nelson, Bay County , Florida Commissioner, on release of 9 inmates from
CCA's Bay County Jail. WJHG, November 20, 2007
''We have very comprehensive and detailed standards which we meet with
our public partners in terms of information that is provided to them.''
CCA spokeswoman Louise Grant on why CCA opposes H.R. 1889 that would require
private prison vendors under contract with the Federal Government to comply with
FIOA requests.
The Morning Call, November 11, 2007
"There is a greater sense of fear and intimidation in this facility than
perhaps any other I have been to."
Texas Youth Commission Ombudsman Will Harrell in his report on conditions at
GEO's Coke County Juvenile Justice Center. Dallas Morning News, October
3, 2007
"We're trying to get on top of the situation."
Epps, Louisiana Mayor Jeff Guice on Emerald Correction's lack of
openness on its West Carroll Detention Center. Houston Chronicle,
July 22, 2007
"I want to make sure that what they're giving us is true and accurate. "I
want something to go directly to corporate office up there that says you guys
have got to be candid when we ask questions."
Hawai'i Department of Public Safety interim director Clayton Frank on CCA's
continuing trouble with door locks at their Red Rock Correctional Facility in
Arizona. Honolulu Advertiser, July 22, 2007
"Right now, I have some serious
concerns and doubt of whether they are providing us with everything."
Hawai'i Department of Public Safety interim director Clayton Frank
on CCA's continuing trouble with door locks at their Red Rock
Correctional Facility in Arizona. Honolulu Advertiser, July 22,
2007
“It’s kind of unusual for me to sit up here and vote for something I
haven’t seen and the city attorney hasn’t read over.”
Adams County, Mississippi Alderman Alderman James “Ricky” Gray after being
asked to vote on an interlocal agreement for CCA that he had not seen.
Natchez Democrat, June 12, 2007
"Private, confidential, or otherwise protected material."
Prison Health Services' attorney on Guilford County, North Carolina, sheriff
BJ Barnes request for information for his own contract with the vendor. News
& Records, June 5, 2007
“Then they all of a sudden cancelled the visit that had been approved for
the Hutto detention center and the New Jersey detention center."
United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants Jorge
Bustamante on being denied access to CCA's T. Don Hutto Correctional Center.
San Antonio Current,
May 23, 2007
“It was the first time I’d heard we were actually going to have to
put up money”
Adams County, MS Supervisor Henry Watts on CCA's not being upfront with all
the costs for their prison proposal. Natchez Democrat, May 3, 2007
"We filed our report two weeks ago. When something is put on the agenda is not
our business."
CCA's Hernando County (FL) Jail warden Don Stewart on why CCA did not report
an accidental release of an inmate to the county commission.
Hernando Today, July 28, 2006
"We received a report that talked about our inmates having a
disturbance. There was nothing in there to make us think anything was wrong."
Idaho Department of Corrections operations
administrator Pam Sonnen on GEO's lack of candor over an incident at its Newton,
Texas facility.
Idaho Statesman,
June 9, 2006
"There's some sort of chink in the communications
there."
Hawai'i Department of Public Safety spokesman Michael Gaede on why they
found out about an inmate's death at CCA's Otter Creek, KY prison through the
family and not CCA. Honolulu Advertiser,
January 4, 2006
"However, we are not able to confirm amounts or any details
on payments or deductions regarding the bonuses as these matters are commercial
in confidence."
Queensland Corrective Services Minister spokeswoman Judy Spence on
confirming GEO Group's contract compliance. Australian,
November 30, 2005
“The
first I heard of this was in the newspaper. What upsets me and others is the
fact that they held several meetings for the Charlotte residents, but were just
trying to fly this over on us”
Dickson County resident Jimmy Stokes over plans by CCA to build a new jail for
the county. Dickson Herald,
December 30, 2004
"Most
of the staff I had discussions with were concerned about being identified if
they shared issues or concerns with me."
Bay County jail contract monitor Roger Hagen on CCA's correctional code of
secrecy. News Herald,
December 29, 2004
My view is that public authorities must resist any suggestion from tenderers that
the price of best value is to agree to withhold information which otherwise
under freedom of information may be made available."
Scottish Information Commissioner Kevin Dunion on the public's access to
secret contract agreements with security company Reliance. BBC,
November
24, 2004
"I don’t know who in the world they’ve
been talking to, but they haven’t been talking to me."
Roger Hagen, Bay County’s correctional program manager on CCA's claim it was
sharing with county officials an "after-action" report about an inmate
takeover at CCA's Bay County Jail. News Herald,
November
9, 2004
"I
was very concerned that we were not notified by Cornell that these people were
even missing."
Florence, Colorado Police Chief Mike Ingle on
Cornell's not notifying local law enforcement after an escape at its Southern
Peaks facility in Colorado. Daily Record,
October 7, 2004
"This
incident made us aware that our policy for contacting local law enforcement
needed to be changed."
Cornell Director of Communication Lisa Tauser on Cornell's not notifying
local law enforcement after an escape at its Southern Peaks facility in
Colorado. Daily Record,
October 6, 2004
"There's a lot of things that go into negotiations with private
prisons that we don't know about and there is a lot that they do that help
Colorado."
Colorado State Senator Ken Kester on his lack of expertise on CCA contracts. Pueblo Chieftain,
July 28, 2004
STAFFING
"It was too unsafe the way it was. There were too many
prisoners for each guard."
Donnie Hedgepeth said he worked at CCA's Adams County Correctional Facility when
it opened in 2009 until sometime in 2010. A riot on May 20, 2012 left one guard
dead. Clarion Ledger, May 21, 2012.
"We expect the highest level of professionalism from all our
contractors, and there are strict guidelines which must be followed when tagging
offenders."
A Ministry of Justice (UK) spokesman on two Group 4 guards tagging a false leg
on an offender who eventually was arrested and in custody before they figured it
out. UKAP, August 29, 2011
"Frankly, I don't understand why a few of them (former CCA
guards) weren't in jail."
Hernando County (FL) Sheriff's Major Michael Page on the one-year anniversary of
the Sheriff's take-over from CCA of the jail. St Petersburg Times, August
28, 2011
“A lot of those that I let go reappeared in the ranks of the privates. At one
point, I asked the privates to stop hiring the people I was firing.”
Former Florida Department of Corrections secretary, Jim McDonough, on
for-profits hiring the public dregs.
Orlando Weekly, May 19, 2011
“No officers were implicated at all. There were just officers not doing their
jobs.”
Mohave County (Arizona) Sheriff Tom
Sheahan on MTC's lax security at its Kingman prison. The Daily News,
May 8, 2011
"These contractors threaten the security of our troops and risk the success
of our mission."
Sen. Carl Levin, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee on their report
on private security in Afghanistan showing companies hiring guards with Taliban
connections, NBC News, October 8, 2010
"We have a lot of very young staff that have not integrated into very strong
security practices."
Odie Washington,
a senior vice president at Management & Training Corp., acknowledged that the
Kingman prison (AZ) employed an inexperienced staff where three violent
prisoners escaped. Arizona Republic, August 22, 2010
“The staffing levels in the visits departments are often inadequate and this
should be addressed as a matter of urgency if the problems are not to continue
and even increase."
Report of the
the Independent Monitoring Board (UK) for the Kalyx (Sodexho) Peterborough
Prison.
Peterborough Today, August 21, 2010
"G4S takes
these matters very seriously and is committed to upholding the highest standards
of honesty and professionalism and to preserving the trust of the public and our
clients. . . . Upon learning of Mr. Owens' recent conduct, G4S immediately
terminated Owens' employment."
Group 4 trying to explain away why they hired a peeping Tom with a previous
criminal background. Miami Herald, August 19, 2010
“I had never seen that before."
Bay County (FL)
Sheriff Frank McKeithen on CCA hiring felons to work as guards. The
News-Herald, July 12, 2010
“The deterioration in safety and security arrangements, particularly
the significant increase in drug use and the weakness in staff supervision of
prisoners, are issues that can and must be addressed.”
Dame Anne Owers, Chief Inspector of Prisons (UK) on a report that condemns
Group 4's Wolds Prison.
The Independent, July 6, 2010
“Bingo nights
is one thing, but still having personnel that can’t figure out how to comport
themselves around women detainees or women in state custody shows that (CCA)
doesn’t learn from its mistakes.”
Judy Greene, criminal justice policy analyst for the New York-based policy
research group Justice Strategies, on CCA's proposal to pretty up immigration
prisons with flowers and bingo nights. Tennessean, June 25, 2010
"When you don't pay well, it's hard to retain good quality folks."
Hernando County
(FL) Sheriff Richard Nugent on paying jail correctional officers up to $7,000
more than CCA. Hernando Today, June 10, 2010
"There was clear evidence at the inquiry that the majority of staff recruited
by Kaylx (sp) were inexperienced within the prison service."
Sheriff Mhari Mactaggart in an inquets into the hanging death of an inmate at
Kalyx's Addiewell Prison in Scotland.
The Scotsman,
February 16, 2010
"Unfortunately, private prisons are run to
make a profit. Ultimately, the company in charge of them has to deliver for
their shareholders and so they have to find ways to make money. The way to do
this is by having fewer staff, paying low wages, investing less money in
training and pensions, and this impacts on the running of the prison. For a
prison to run properly, you need the guards and the prisoners to understand each
other and work with each other, and that requires experienced guards. That takes
an investment in training and keeping staff, which can be at odds with the need
to deliver a profit."
Former Chief Inspector of Prisons (Scotland) Sir Clive Fairweather on the cause
of a riot at the Kalyx (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. Edinburgh Evening News,
January 28, 2010
"Therefore you have the minimum number of
staff, you have the minimum amount of training and it's certainly my experience
with Kilmarnock that violence and the like was a problem until eventually
staffing levels got to a slightly better stage."
Clive Fairweather, who has previously inspected the private prison at
Kilmarnock, Scotland on a riot at Kalyx's (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. BBC,
January 26, 2010
"He indicated they were undermanned, understaffed; he didn't have the budget
he needed that he thought he could run the facility to the best of his ability."
Former LCS Warden Art Crews about the Coastal Bend Detention Center (TX) and LCS.
WEAU,
December 29, 2009
"Recent incidents reflect the sentiment of prisoners who are fully aware of
the staff's lack of ability to contain the prisoners here in an emergency
situation."
Serco employee about staffing issues at the Acacia Prison (Australia). The
Western Australian,
December 31, 2009
“They will hire any friggin’ warm body because they go through staff so
much.”
Lorene Gendron, who worked for PHS (in VT) for two years as an inmate advocate,
says that poor support, salaries and working conditions mean high turnover.
Ashley Ellis died less than two days after entering a Vermont prison from the
careless and negligent operation of a privatized for-profit (PHS) prison
healthcare system. In These Times,
December 8, 2009
"The staff ratio just wasn't there."
Mona Brown, a floor staffer at the Forbes Juvenile Attention Facility in Topeka,
Kansas after a lawsuit was filed for a 12-year-old boy to be repeatedly raped by
his roommate over three days. Topeka Capital-Journal, October 18, 2009
“Not only sexual abuse or physical abuse but death investigations also, so
they vary. The different cases and situations, they vary."
Kentucky State Trooper Mike Goble about incidents at CCA's Otter Creek Prison. WKYT,
August 17, 2009
“He was involved. He was a suspect. I don’t care if he was a corrections
officer."
Pima County (AZ) Deputy Dawn Barkman on the shooting of a CCA guard who had just
committed a home invasion robbery. Arizona Daily Star,
July 22,
2009
"It's viewed as a major concern."
CCA's Hernando County Jail (FL) Warden Russell Washburn on reports that one of
his guards was arrested for rape and sexual contact with minors. The employee
has not been fired yet. Hernando Today,
July 2, 2009
``We haven't been made whole. It would be irresponsible for us to continue
doing business with an entity that we believe has overbilled us.''
Miami-Dade County (FL) spokeswoman Victoria Mallette on being sued by Wackenhut
(Group 4) after an audit and whistleblower suit uncovered ghost employees.
Miami Herald,
April 30, 2009
"If it is true that staff employed to work with asylum-seekers and immigrants
are members of the BNP then it is yet another sign that the Home Office are
allowing for the mistreatment of immigrants in this country."
Labour MP and anti-racist campaigner Diane Abbott on revelations that two
private prison guards were members of an ultra-right wing political group.
Politics.Co.UK
January 14, 2009
"I hope you understand how seriously we're taking not only the report but the
safety of our inmates. They have an ongoing staffing issue that doesn't appear
to be able to be solved."
Idaho Department of Corrections Director Brent Reinke about cancelling GEO's
contract for their Bill Clayton (TX) Facility. AP,
November 6, 2008
“We do see turnover. But I don't think it’s turnover because of the facility
itself, I think it's turnover because 'I can make more money.'”
Torrance County (NM) Sheriff Clarence Gibson trying to explain away
his CCA's jail highest level of rape then any jail in the US. KOAT,
October 1, 2008
"Clearly this is a cause for concern."
Virginia Kice, a spokeswoman for ICE about GEO Group falsifying employee
background checks. AP,
September 30, 2008
It's appalling that a person paid to counsel inmates against drug
abuse is charged with trying to smuggle heroin and cocaine into the jail, the
exact opposite of what he was paid to do."
NY Department of Investigation Commissioner Rose Gill Hearn regarding the PHS
employee caught smuggling drugs into Rikers Island.
New York Sun,
September 19, 2008
“It is clear that staff complacency and physical plant vulnerabilities played
a key role in the escape.”
John Gilbert, CEC’s deputy director/secure facility division on his staff's role
in the escape of four inmates from their Columbiana (OH) Jail. Youngstown
Vindicator,
September 12, 2008
"I was proud to be a detention centre officer, protecting Australia's
borders. Then I changed. I became a monster, a cowboy, like all the other
officers. They were all driven crazy. When I look back, I just think - what the
hell did I do that for? To end up hating people for no reason."
Former ACM (GEO Group) guard Carol Wiltshire on what happens to workers at
detention centers. Sidney Morning Herald,
September 13, 2008
"Our correctional officers wear their uniform proudly. They stand upright."
Louise Grant, vice-president of marketing and communications for Corrections
Corporation of America, about her guards. Pahrump Valley Times,
August
22, 2008
"The Monitoring Team has found that the lack of stable and effective
leadership at the vendor-level remains a concern."
Independent monitor regarding Correctional Medical Service's problems at the
Delaware Department of Corrections.
News Journal,
July 30, 2008
"They've got to get this right."
Sue Cain, Metro (Nashville, Tennessee) law director about Wackenhut's need to
pay taxpayers back the $840,000 for a stolen laptop computer and ghost employees
and explain just how company officials intend for it not to happen again.
Tennessean,
May 17, 2008
“It might be more realistic to empty the centre briefly, so that it
can be relaunched with a properly trained and reinvigorated staff, focused on
plenty of good-quality, purposeful activity, dynamic security, and an emphasis
on appropriate behaviour within clear boundaries.”
Anne Owers, UK Chief Inspector of Prisons, suggestion to close the jail after
finding a lack of control and order at
Group 4's Oakhill Secure Training Unit.
The Times,
March 17, 2008
"Moreover, there has been consistent turnover at staff-level positions, and,
at [Young Correctional Institution] in particular, there is a problem with staff
insubordination that needs to be addressed because it affects inmate medical and
mental health services negatively."
Delaware independent monitor Joshua W. Martin III in a 229-page report on
Correctional Medical Services health care in this state. News Journal,
February 1, 2008
"Last week, our office began training all jail staff and Cornell agreed to
strategic planning to provide more training to hire more and more qualified
people from a larger geographic area."
New Mexico 12th Judicial District Attorney Scot Key on a Grand Jury
investigation into Cornell operations at the Lincoln County Detention Center.
Ruidoso News, January 25, 2008
"We were told that CMS can unilaterally choose to reduce provider staffing
from five days a week to two days a week, if it has trouble recruiting, and that
CMS is not subject to any penalty or disincentive."
National Commission on Correctional Health Care on lack of oversight by the
Michigan Department of Corrections over its contract with Correctional Medical
Services. Detroit News,
January 23, 2008
"Custody officers claimed that staffing levels could at times be dangerously
low, especially in ‘A’ wing and at weekends. They said that two members of staff
had been assaulted over the past year, while there had also been a large number
of less serious incidents. We sensed generally that staff seemed to be even more
concerned about safety than they had been a year ago (and being under complement
could also have contributed to this). Examples were cited where it was
impossible to arrange relief cover for toilet breaks, meaning that prisoners
were left unsupervised, except by CCTV, during these periods."
Scotland Chief Prison Inspector
Clive Fairweather on a recent report on Premier's Kilmarnock Prison.
Scotland on Sunday, January 6, 2008
"Your body is not designed to work 12 hours a day. The schedule is brutal. It's
a killer."
Former Wackenhut (Group 4) guard Robert Hall on his work schedule at the
Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station. AP,
December 4, 2007
"You wonder where the hell were the detention officers in all of this."
MTC inmate attorney Gary Mitchell on the lack of staffing at the Santa Fe
County Detention Center at the time his client killed another inmate. New
Mexican,
November 19, 2007
"I was working five, six days a week, 12-hour days, overtime. "It's hard
to get people to go into that line of work."
Former Coke County, Texas guard John Christman on GEO's trouble with
staffing. Dallas Morning News,
July 29, 2007
"They have been understaffed"
GEO guard's wife, Twilla Deaton on staffing issues after a riot at GEO's New
Castle CF. The Star Press,
April 25, 2007
"There were serious security concerns"
Arizona Department of Corrections spokeswoman Katie Decker on concerns over
GEO's staffing levels at their New Castle CF in Indiana after a riot by over 500
inmates.
The Indianapolis Star,
April 25, 2007
"There's just not enough
personnel. More security officers and more detention officers, should be placed
there"
Joe Magallan, a deputy with the U.S. Marshals Service
in Texas, on LCS' problems after an escape of six inmates from their East
Hidalgo Detention Center. Houston Chronicle,
September 21, 2006
"The
few privatized jails I've seen have a tendency to pay minimum wage or slightly
above, so you're going to have a problem with staff turnover."
American Jails managing editor Ken Kerle on pay and turnover at for-profits. Beaufort Gazette,
November 12, 2005
"Staffing is hard to come by"
MTC's Santa Fe County Detention Facility Warden Kerry Dixon on trouble keeping
medical staff. Tennessean,
September 12, 2005
"We don't hire questionable
people, and that's the embarrassing part"
GRW President Gil Walker on his company hiring guards with criminal records
at their at their Brush Correctional Facility in Colorado. Rocky Mountain
News,
March 23, 2005
"Until there's more staff, there's not going to be a drastic
improvement"
Former PHS administrator Stephanie Lawson on turnover at the Donaldson
Correctional Facility in Jefferson County, Alabama. Birmingham News,
March 18, 2005
"We knew the prison was
full of thieves but we thought they were behind bars"
An insider at Premier's Kilmarnock jail after a staff member was
caught on camera stealing inmates candy.
Sunday Mail,
October 3, 2004
“We’re working 12 to 16 hour shifts and we’re tired. No one get raises
because we’ve burned up all the overtime because the program director didn’t
hire anybody for three or four months in a row.”
CiviGenics employee David
Lucero on staff burnout. Ruidoso News,
August 26, 2004
"We're
going to have to attract more workers, more than we did before . "Part of
the workforce is going to have to move here."
Toole County Commissioner Allan Underdal acknowledging the difficulty in
finding qualified guards for expanding CCA's Crossroads prison.
Great Falls
Tribune,
August 20, 2004
"This guy tells me, 'I'm doing a 480-year sentence and I'm 20 years in.
A lot of these guys (guards) were bagging groceries last week. Who do you think
is going to be better at what they do: me at being a prisoner or them at being a
guard?"
Former New Mexico DOC Secretary Rob Perry on why he he wouldn't allow
maximum security inmates at private prisons. Albuquerque Tribune,
July 26, 2004
"At the end of the day, we were beset
with some difficulties in attracting and training qualified staff."
Paul Doucette, Cornell VP of Business Development and Public Affairs, on not
being able to maintain staffing at their New Morgan Academy in Pennsylvania. Daily
Republic,
September 4, 2003
TRAINING
"(N)o training, no idea and no perceived intention to provide
any welfare."
A former Serco employee at Curtin Detention Centre (Australia) says treatment of
detainees by some staff members was "outrageously brutal" and they were bullied
constantly. The West Australian, August 25, 2011
"Basically, from what I've seen, the new recruits were just basically put on
the floor, no training whatsoever, they were being told that they would be
trained as they were."
A Serco guard quoted in a wide-ranging report delivered by Comcare, the Federal
Government's (Australia) workplace safety agency. ABC, August 11, 2011
"She just made a colossal mistake."
Delco
County (PA) Superintendent John Reilly Jr., who oversees CEC's performance on
the county's behalf, on the recent "accidental" release of inmates at the George
W. Hill Prison. Philadelphia Daily News, August 27, 2010
"There was clear evidence at the inquiry that the majority of
staff recruited by Kaylx (sp) were inexperienced within the prison service."
Sheriff Mhari Mactaggart in an inquest into the hanging death of an inmate at
Kalyx's Addiewell Prison in Scotland. The Scotsman, February 16, 2010
"Unfortunately, private prisons are run to make a profit. Ultimately, the
company in charge of them has to deliver for their shareholders and so they have
to find ways to make money. The way to do this is by having fewer staff, paying
low wages, investing less money in training and pensions, and this impacts on
the running of the prison. For a prison to run properly, you need the guards and
the prisoners to understand each other and work with each other, and that
requires experienced guards. That takes an investment in training and keeping
staff, which can be at odds with the need to deliver a profit."
Former Chief Inspector of Prisons (Scotland) Sir Clive Fairweather on the cause
of a riot at the Kalyx (Sodexho) Addiewell Prison. Edinburgh Evening News,
January 28, 2010
"Undoubtedly, a private company would pay its employees significantly
lower wages and provide them lesser training to realize cost savings. This would
lead to higher staff turnover, low morale and place public safety at risk."
Arizona DOC Director Charles Ryan in a letter to Gov. Jan Brewer on a plan to
sell its public prisons to for-profit corporations.
Arizona Republic,
June 14, 2009
"It wasn't what we were after. It wasn't what I would have
expected."
Vermont Department of Corrections Commissioner Andrew Pallito on pulling his
state's inmates from LCS's Perry County
Correctional Center in Alabama because of lack of response to concerns
over security and inadequately trained staff. Bennington Banner,
June 9,
2009
"I didn't know what I was doing and didn't have anyone to help me. I
didn't have a clue. I felt inadequate and stupid because I didn't know the
routine and prisoners were trying to tell me what to do."
Former Premier (now Serco) guard Ann Hinshelwood on the lack of training she
received after a riot at the HMS Bowhouse prison. Sunday Mail,
May
24, 2009
"Obviously, whether he was enticed or lured or not, we've got a
major breakdown in training with the staff at Otter Creek, and a problem with
accountability up there of guards if a person can go in there and commit this
type of act against one of our inmates."
Hawai'i State Sen. Will Espero, chairman of the Senate Public Safety Committee,
on the rape of an Hawai'i inmate at CCA's Otter Creek (KY) Prison. Honolulu
Advertiser,
October 2, 2008
"I was dealing with people tying razor wire around their throats, using
razor blades, knitting needles that they would sharpen, rope … overdosing on
Panadol, detergent, chemicals, gravel."
Former Group 4/Wackenhut Woomera Detention Center (Australia) worker described
how, with no appropriate training, she had to counsel up to 12 people a day who
had self-harmed over their indefinite detention. The Age,
September
19, 2008
"The key word there is proper."
Columbiana County (OH) Sheriff David Smith regarding how four inmates
escaped from the CiviGenics jail after employees failed in their head count.
Salem News,
August 20, 2008
"The man was unshaven and did not have a uniform on. As everything
happened so quickly I did not think to ask for ID, or that he may have been a
bogus caller."
Michael Chafer, of Hindon Walk, Scunthorpe (UK), received a visit from Group 4
Securicor after the firm was given the wrong details. Scunthorpe Telegraph,
June 3, 2008
"It was around the availability of personnel. The training of personnel.
The certification. Licensing of personnel. Nothing deliberate. It was just a
matter of logistics and timing. "
St. Louis, Missouri MetroLink transit agency President Robert Baer on why
Wackenhut (Group 4) lost its contract.
St Louis Post -Dispatch,
April 26,
2008
“It might be more realistic to empty the centre briefly, so that
it can be re-launched with a properly trained and reinvigorated staff, focused on
plenty of good-quality, purposeful activity, dynamic security, and an emphasis
on appropriate behaviour within clear boundaries.”
Anne Owers, UK Chief Inspector of Prisons, suggestion to close the jail after
finding a lack of control and order at
Group 4's Oakhill Secure Training Unit.
The Times,
March 17, 2008
“Staff don’t like the way they are treated by management. They feel there
is a lack of training. Some don’t want to be there. They are trained for half a
day, once a week. They don’t feel they’re learning anything. It’s about time the
Assembly looked at what was going on."
Former Group 4 warden on lack of training at Group 4's Parc Prison.
Wales on Sunday,
December 2, 2007
"I assume they have some training, but I don't know."
Epps, Louisiana Police Chief Roosevelt Porter on Emerald Correction's
lack of openness on its West Carroll Detention Center. Houston
Chronicle,
July 22, 2007
"Straight from the start I had expressed concern about the level of
support and training. I told senior management about it and they didn't do
anything."
Global Solutions Ltd Guard Daniel Daymond after a scathing report on an
inmate's suicide. The Guardian,
April 3, 2007
"None
of the staff have training with psych patients and the centre is not properly
equipped to deal with these people"
GEO correctional officer Bruna
Moressi about the Melbourne Custody Centre, Australia. Herald
Sun
November 18, 2004
"Nobody trained me."
Registered nurse Deb Moore on CMS at the North State CF
in Newport, VT. WCAX Channel 3 News,
July 29, 2004
|